Mary Hague Kelly Part 2 of 2
Nov 9, 2026 · 55m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the 1989 murder of Mary Kelly in Dallas and the 33-year investigation that led to the arrest of David Rojas, a neighbor who had been overlooked by initial detectives. Through advanced genetic genealogy and DNA testing on preserved evidence, investigators identified Rojas as the killer, who had previously claimed a consensual relationship with the victim. The narrative covers the 2022 trial, where the prosecution overcame defense arguments regarding flawed evidence handling and a missing murder weapon to secure a guilty verdict for capital murder.
Topics discussed
Introduction: On Being Human
DNA breakthrough identifies suspect lineage
Identifying David and Fred Rojas
Surreptitious DNA collection and fingerprint analysis
Arrest and initial suspect statement
The implausible consensual sex defense
Family reaction and capital murder charges
Missing evidence and DNA confirmation
Show intro segment
Trial begins: Opening statements
Crime scene and medical examiner testimony
Autopsy findings and detective testimony
Neighbor testimony on Mary's life
Testimony from Rojas' ex-wife
Forensic serology and cold case unit
Debate over the extension cord DNA
DNA lab issues and defense cross-examination
Closing arguments: Prosecution's case
Closing arguments: Defense's critique
Show intro segment
Prosecution rebuttal on evidence and motive
Final arguments on injuries and DNA
Verdict and family reaction
Sentencing and victim impact statement
Show intro segment
Rojas' background and prior abuse history
Details of prior sexual assaults
Other criminal convictions and arrests
Car theft ring and burglary charges
DUI arrest and probation violations
Dismissal of child abuse charges
Reconstruction of the crime and conclusion
Outro and show support information
Credits and production details
More from DNA: ID
Listen ad-free on Castria