DOE ID Gary Herbst
Sep 7, 2026 · 52m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the 2017 discovery of a human skull in Barron County, Wisconsin, which was identified via genetic genealogy as Gary Herbst, a man missing since 2013. Investigators uncovered evidence that his wife, Connie, and son, Austin, murdered him to escape his abusive behavior and concealed the body by rolling it in a carpet and dumping it in a rural area. After years of investigation, Austin confessed to shooting his father while he slept, claiming he acted to protect his mother from imminent violence.
Topics discussed
Introduction and network podcast promotion
Discovery of human skull in Barron County driveway
Police search and recovery of remains and clothing
Autopsy results confirming homicide by gunshot
Forensic anthropology and initial DNA database searches
Genetic genealogy identifies likely relative
Official identification of John Doe as Gary Herbst
Gary Herbst's background and 2013 disappearance
Investigation of missing person status and family interviews
Connie Herbst's account of the disappearance and theft
Investigator suspicions regarding Connie's story
DNA confirmation and Austin's initial interview
Confrontation with evidence and Austin's confession
Neighbor testimony regarding yard sale and suspicious activity
Forensic evidence of blood and body disposal at home
Search warrant execution and digital evidence discovery
Text messages and continued investigation of the crime scene
Austin's confession to shooting and body disposal
Charges filed and details of the murder and cover-up
Sentencing arguments and plea deals for both defendants
Austin's testimony on domestic abuse and the shooting
Prosecution arguments and final sentencing for Austin
Debate on evidence and final thoughts on the case
Outro and Patreon subscription promotion
More from DNA: ID
Listen ad-free on Castria