The Demise Of A Mediocre Man - Michael Pittman - Part 3
Oct 27, 2026 · 1h 42m
More True Crime podcasts · More Comedy podcasts
Summary
This episode of Crime in Sports concludes the Michael Pittman saga, detailing his guilty plea to endangerment, 30-day jail sentence, and subsequent three-game NFL suspension. Hosts James Petrogallo and Jimmy Wissman critique the league’s lenient handling of domestic violence while discussing Pittman’s return to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. The segment also covers his 2005 season, highlighting his six fumbles and the team’s struggles, before teasing an upcoming story about a violent hockey player.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: OrderlyMeds GLP-1 treatment
Show intro and upcoming tour dates
Weekly news: old articles and tragedies
Pittman's 2004 domestic violence charges
Plea deal and Bucs' initial response
Jail sentence and NFL review
Jail conditions and release details
Return to Bucs and suspension
Bucs' 2005 season struggles and QBs
Pittman's 100-yard game vs Chiefs
78-yard TD and media reception
Criticism of Pittman's 'problem'
Fumbles and 1,000-yard milestone
Fumble karma and team turnover issues
Cadillac Williams draft and role
Pittman's emotional breakdown and ball control
Sean Taylor incident and retaliation
Taylor's legal issues and Pittman's motorcycle
Bucs' QB spiral and Jeff Garcia
Interview: house guests and childhood
Injuries and 2008 Broncos signing
Broncos camp and career stats
UFL stint and 2011 arrest
Post-NFL life and social media
Trading cards and Slapshot connection
Outro, shoutouts, and sponsor
More from Crime in Sports
Listen ad-free on Castria