Crime in Sports Crime in Sports

Misunderstood Messiah - Bill "Goldie" Goldthorpe - Part 2

Nov 10, 2026 · 2h 14m

Summary

This episode of Crime in Sports profiles Bill Goldthorpe, a volatile 1970s minor league hockey player known for his aggressive style and distinctive blonde afro. The hosts detail his chaotic career, including legal battles over his playing rights, a near-fatal incident involving a thrown bottle, and a controversial attempt to debut as a professional boxer that was blocked by the New York State Athletic Commission. The segment also covers his subsequent moves to other teams and the numerous suspensions and assaults that defined his reputation as a "misunderstood messiah" in the sport.

Topics discussed

Serval AI ad Show intro and Patreon plug Early career: Syracuse and Erie Binghamton Dusters debut and bottle incident Boxing rumors and tennis jokes Boxing training and the canceled fight Mint Mobile ad Commission denies boxing license Legal troubles and league hopping Richmond and Utica stints NHL blackballing controversy OnDeck ad Thunder Bay and Slapshot connection WHA, IHL, and New Haven Nighthawks San Diego Gulls and street clothes incident Spokane Flyers and bodybuilding Shooting incident and Moncton Alpines Retirement, old timers, and Slapshot lore Later life, interviews, and eBay sales Outro and Patreon shoutouts

More from Crime in Sports

Brain Damaged Fire Bug - Daniel Kerr
Nov 16, 2026
The Riotstarter - Bill "Goldie" Goldthorpe - Part 1
Nov 3, 2026
The Demise Of A Mediocre Man - Michael Pittman - Part 3
Oct 27, 2026
Superman's Hummer - Michael Pittman Sr. - Part 2
Oct 20, 2026
Domestic Excuses - Michael Pittman Sr. - Part 1
Oct 13, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria