Crime in Sports Crime in Sports

The Riotstarter - Bill "Goldie" Goldthorpe - Part 1

Nov 3, 2026 · 1h 53m

Summary

Hosts James Petrogallo and Jimmy Wissman introduce a multi-part series on Goldie Goldthorpe, a violent WHA hockey player described as a real-life Ogie Oglethorpe. The episode details his early life in Ontario, his history of juvenile arrests, and his professional career with the Syracuse Blazers, where he was notorious for attacking referees and opponents. The hosts also preview a segment connecting the Nazi regime to the 1960s LSD movement.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Bath & Body Works holiday scents Intro and Small Town Murder show promo Episode topic: The Harlem Globetrotters Patreon promo and introduction of Bill Goldthorpe Goldthorpe's physical stats and background Discussion on 1970s rival sports leagues Hosts' opinions on NFL integrity and gambling Goldthorpe's early life and WW2 veteran father Goldthorpe's aggressive style and street fights Training with his brother and midget hockey league Coaches' views on Goldthorpe's talent and behavior Jail time for assault and playing hockey from prison Origin of the Thunder Bay Vulcans team name Incident: Shoving a referee and breaking a denture Suspensions and charges for common assault Comparison to the Zodiac killer and team discipline Sponsor: CarGurus car shopping service Playoff protest: Team stays in dressing room Punching a linesman and police escort Escaping angry fans and police intervention Transition to professional hockey in Syracuse Teammates: Jamie Kennedy and Carlo Ugolini Fighting in a Maine uniform and local theater ads League officials ban 'molesting' of referees Suspensions for overhandling linesmen Media coverage: 'Harpo the Unbeatable' Goldthorpe's reputation and local dating life WHA Jersey Knights working agreement Media nickname: 'The Blonde' Incident: Hit by a can of Bush beer Coach Ron Ingram's defense of Goldthorpe Goldthorpe's preference for road fights Return from suspension and Cougars game Brawl involving fans and open penalty box Seven players ejected in a single game Arrested on a plane and left in Green Bay jail Riot: Fans climb plexiglass, police use dogs Stalling for time and escaping the parking lot Sponsor: Roe GLP-1 weight loss Sponsor: Squarespace and Shine banking Team defense: Sticks ready at the dressing room door Fans challenging players to fight Season stats and comparison to football players Teammate names: Gord Gallant and Dick Paradise Stick confrontation with John Schella Photo description: Goldthorpe and Schella posing Training with Gordy and speed bag Friendship with John Schella and fighting style Difficulty finding fights in Minnesota Assignment to Syracuse and rookie of the year The Four Hour War: Dusters vs Blazers Record-breaking penalty minutes in the Four Hour War Assault charges and refusal to report to Johnstown Johnstown Jets and Goldthorpe's refusal Nickname: Gold Fists and potential suspension NAHL stats: 287 penalty minutes 1974-75 season: Moving between three teams Flexing in the penalty box and Baltimore Blades Goldthorpe grooming in the dressing room Quote: Baltimore is a great town not to be in Arrest at Hilton Hotel: Alleged rape charge Jail and bail for the rape allegation Media reporting the accused's home address Teammate points finger: 'It was him' Harassment charge: Calling a cop a 'puke' Comparison to NFL suspensions (Pittman, Tucker) Grand jury no-bill on rape case Trial for third-degree assault from January brawl Defense: Trouble came to him in the box Trial evidence: Combat photos and stick slash Sentencing: Judge blames hockey and fans Warning to spectators and attorney's reaction Unrelated news: Tragedy at a local event Binghamton fans expected to love Goldthorpe Trade to Denver Spurs and WHA status San Diego Mariners need a fighter Unrelated news: Knife-wielding bandit changes mind Goldthorpe claims he will be the mayor Discussion on Serbian players and Drazen Petrovic Comparison to Carlos Boozer and Dennis Rodman Practice behavior and Goldthorpe's vocabulary Passion for the game despite bad language Ad: Wadsworth Steaks in Finger Lakes Erie Blades: One game, 22 penalty minutes Syracuse Blazers win over Erie Multiple game misconducts in the fight Episode wrap-up and preview of next week Promo: Small Town Murder show in Medford, MA Patreon promo: Drug culture and Nazi history Credits: Producers and Thomas Smith in Birmingham Credits: Additional staff and Nelly reference Credits: Patrons and final thanks

More from Crime in Sports

Brain Damaged Fire Bug - Daniel Kerr
Nov 16, 2026
Misunderstood Messiah - Bill "Goldie" Goldthorpe - Part 2
Nov 10, 2026
The Demise Of A Mediocre Man - Michael Pittman - Part 3
Oct 27, 2026
Superman's Hummer - Michael Pittman Sr. - Part 2
Oct 20, 2026
Domestic Excuses - Michael Pittman Sr. - Part 1
Oct 13, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria