Hosts Nick and Carl review the 1977 disappearance of 17-year-old Yvonne Regler from a Sunoco gas station in Ohio. They analyze the timeline, noting she was last seen at 1:25 p.m. before customers found the station empty. The hosts criticize early police theories suggesting she ran away, arguing instead that her abduction likely occurred at the pump. They emphasize that her personal belongings remained inside, indicating foul play rather than voluntary departure.