True Crime Garage True Crime Garage

Burger Chef Murders /// Part 2 /// 970

Nov 18, 2026 · 45m

Summary

This episode investigates the 1978 Burger Chef murders in Speedway, Indiana, featuring a new interview with employee Brian Kring who witnessed the initial crime scene. The hosts analyze conflicting suspect descriptions, the "Greenwood suspect" lead, and the controversial testimony of Alan Pruitt, while reviewing the timeline of funerals and early police efforts. They also discuss the discovery of Mary Ann Higginbotham’s body and the ongoing challenges in solving this enduring mystery.

Topics discussed

Sponsored segment: Tremphaya for Crohn's and UC Sponsored segment: Mint Mobile holiday deal Show introduction and host greeting Beer review and listener shout-outs Introduction to the 1978 Burger Chef murders Police mishandling and initial robbery theory Witness testimony and suspect descriptions Ongoing investigation and forensic updates Criticism of Speedway Police secrecy Autopsy details and media pressure Theory of pre-planned robbery and recognition Speculation on van and multiple assailants Funeral services for Jane and Ruth Ruth Shelton's memorial and community grief Release of suspect composite sketches Detailed description of the clean-shaven suspect Detailed description of the bearded suspect Conflicting witness accounts and hair color Complications in the robbery plan and FBI files Analysis of cash amount and insider knowledge Timing of the crime and witness limitations Surveillance tactics and suspect behavior Inconsistencies in suspect descriptions over time Height discrepancies in witness recollections Clothing and physical details of the clean-shaven man Clothing details of the bearded man Investigation of lookalikes and hotline tips Debate on witness reliability and mutton chops Questioning the presence of the two men Possibility of additional perpetrators Investigation of letters and phone calls Harassment of the Shelton family Suspicions regarding a victim's brother Mark Flemons' funeral and witness hypnosis Busts, photos, and influx of tips Sponsored segment: Mint Mobile holiday deal Sponsored segment: SimpliSafe alarm systems Anonymous tip received by newspaper Reward system and tip verification process Findings: shooter, stabber, and driver Analysis of the tipster's motive and immunity Claim that killers left Indiana Mark Flemons' survival theory and split-up Letter alleging jealousy and motive Greenwood suspect bragging at a bar David Kithcart questioning and polygraph S.W. Wilkins identified as bearded suspect Wilkins shaves and police focus shifts Neighbor identified and gang connections Review of other robberies and violence levels Identification of suspects in other cases Transition to the Mary Ann Higginbotham case Discovery of skull in barrel and context Alan Pruitt's account of the abduction Critique of Pruitt's story and credibility Tim Willoughby's disappearance and Pruitt's status Failure to prove van usage and man-hours spent Formation of multi-agency task force in 1980 Host reflection on overlapping theories Host's theory on van and three perpetrators Sponsored segment: Experian subscription management Sponsored segment: Skills-based hiring

More from True Crime Garage

Burger Chef Murders /// Part 3 /// 971
Nov 18, 2026
Burger Chef Murders /// Part 1 /// 969
Nov 18, 2026
Tom Brown /// Part 5 /// 968
Nov 11, 2026
Tom Brown /// Part 4 /// 967
Nov 11, 2026
Tom Brown /// Part 3 /// 966
Nov 5, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria