Tracy Harkness ////// Part 4 of 4
Sep 10, 2026 · 22m
Summary
Hosts Nick and Captain discuss the 1992 murder of Tracy Harkness, highlighting a thorough investigation that included an FBI profile identifying the killer as a known male with anger issues. They analyze the evidence, noting that while David Seelock fits the profile, the case remains unsolved due to missing murder weapons and conflicting alibis. The episode emphasizes the potential for modern DNA testing on preserved evidence to finally solve the case and encourages listeners to share information with the Grove City Police Department.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: R.J. Decker
Sponsor: Squarespace
Intro, beer review, and donations
Overview of the Tracy Harkness investigation
FBI profile and suspect characteristics
Analyzing persons of interest and alibis
Missing murder weapon and the claw hammer
DNA evidence and the apartment key mystery
Solo perpetrator vs. group and conflicting stories
Police statements and public appeals for help
The importance of public pressure on cold cases
Physical evidence and potential for new DNA testing
How to submit tips to law enforcement
Outro and promotion of Off the Record
Sponsor: Long Winded podcast
Sponsor: Taco Bell
Listen ad-free on Castria