Tom Brown /// Part 1 /// 964
Nov 4, 2026 · 53m
More True Crime podcasts · More History podcasts
Summary
This episode investigates the 2016 disappearance of 18-year-old Thomas Kelly Brown in Canadian, Texas, detailing his final night out with friends and the subsequent search efforts. The hosts analyze conflicting timelines, the discovery of Tom’s abandoned vehicle near sewage ponds, and the controversial conduct of local law enforcement, including Sheriff Nathan Lewis. They highlight the case’s unresolved nature, noting missing personal items and contradictory witness accounts that have left the small town divided.
Topics discussed
Intro: 30-year-old unsolved murder case
Sponsor: Lowe's Veterans Day offer
Beer of the Week: Ghost in the Machine
Listener shoutouts and beer run
Tom Brown's background and disappearance
Family history and move to Perryton
Introduction of Sheriff Nathan Lewis
Timeline: Thanksgiving Eve evening
Cruising with friends and music
The walking bridge and photo evidence
Phone activity and curfew discussion
Gas station transaction discrepancies
Debit card timing and gas tank size
Surveillance footage and camera issues
Last known location and phone death
Sponsor: BetterHelp
Sponsor: IXL
Sponsor: Mint Mobile
Sponsor: Quince
Search efforts and meeting locations
Phone pings and vehicle movement
Friends' reactions and initial search
Deputy Pine Gregory's response
Critique of law enforcement response
Search at middle school and roads
Deputy shift change and protocols
Contradictory statements from Tucker
Vehicle sighting at 5:28 AM
Sheriff Lewis's initial skepticism
High school practice and lookout
Discovery of the abandoned Durango
Scene details and missing items
Blood evidence on driver's door
Analysis of blood and vehicle custody
Discovery of shell casing
Outro and next episode preview
Sponsor: Pandora and Taboola
More from True Crime Garage
Listen ad-free on Castria