True Crime Garage True Crime Garage

The Zodiac Killer? /// Part 2 /// 961

Oct 7, 2026 · 47m

Summary

This episode investigates the Zodiac case, arguing that Inspector Dave Tosky fabricated later letters to maintain media attention and that the Lake Berryessa attack was likely a copycat crime. The hosts analyze the discrepancies in witness descriptions and the failure of police to link suspect George Waters to the Napa murders. They also examine the Paul Stein murder, suggesting it may have been committed by a different serial cab robber, Robert Brommel, rather than the original Zodiac killer.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Whale Fall movie Darlene's relationship and Dean's alibi Mike's odd clothing and potential crime Mike's background and relationship with Darlene Comparing suspect descriptions to witnesses Eyewitness reliability and the shooting incident Flaws in height estimation and witness sketches George Waters and the Vallejo suspect connection Boot print weight analysis and 1969 averages Gas station witness and Arthur Lee Allen Lake Berryessa attack details and other witnesses Zodiac costume and Tate-LaBianca parallels Sponsors: Acorns, Mint Mobile, Quince, Greenlight Manson murders comparison and Zodiac symbol Payphone call and latent fingerprint analysis Handwriting analysis flaws and copycat theory Inspector Dave Tosky and media manipulation FBI investigation into Tosky and letter removal Paul Stein murder and Tosky's crime scene role Robert Brommel and the cab driver robberies Zodiac's media strategy and episode outro
Listen ad-free on Castria