She Deserved to Live ///// 962
Oct 21, 2026 · 58m
More True Crime podcasts · More History podcasts
Summary
Hosts Nick and the Captain discuss the 2024 murder of 24-year-old Brooke Stratton in Madison, Wisconsin, highlighting her documented fears of her abusive partner, James Barnes Morris. The episode details the investigation into her disappearance, including her last sighting with Morris and his subsequent incriminating statements to friends. After her body was recovered from a retention pond, Morris’s shifting alibis led to his arrest and eventual guilty plea to first-degree reckless homicide.
Topics discussed
Sponsors: Fear Fest and Lowe's Pro Desk
Guinness review and Domestic Violence Awareness Month intro
Case background: Brooke Stratton and James Barnes Morris
Journal entries revealing fear and abuse in the relationship
Timeline: The party on September 29th and last sighting
Eyewitness accounts of James's distress and wet sneakers
Alarming statements made by James to friends at the party
Missing person report and initial police investigation
Sponsors: BetterHelp, Acorns, Mint Mobile, and Quince
Search intensifies and body found in retention pond
Police custody, evidence discovery, and initial statements
Interrogation tactics and shifting alibis from James
Homicide investigation, medical examiner, and community memorial
Discussion on victim dynamics, infidelity, and threat perception
Charges filed and plea deal negotiations in 2025
Sentencing for first-degree reckless homicide and victim impact
Family statement, James's apology, and case conclusion
Outro, recommended listening, and sponsors: Instagram and IXL
More from True Crime Garage
Listen ad-free on Castria