Interstate Strangler /// Part 1 /// 954
Sep 15, 2026 · 54m
More True Crime podcasts · More History podcasts
Summary
Hosts Nick and Captain investigate the unsolved I-70 Strangler case, a series of murders targeting men in Indiana and Ohio between 1980 and 1991. They analyze FBI profiles that identified two distinct killers, contrasting the violent methods of one with the strangulations attributed to the other. The episode explores how the case later linked to Herbert Bomeister, the Fox Hollow murderer, and Larry Eiler, while discussing the complexities of jurisdiction and the treatment of LGBTQ+ victims during that era.
Topics discussed
Intro and TV PI promo
Ashley Furniture advertisement
Beer sponsor and show introduction
Overview of I-70 Strangler and suspects
Larry Eiler and the gay bar connection
Task force formation and early victims
Splitting the investigation into two killers
FBI criminal profiles of the two suspects
Victim details and media coverage
Analysis of victim demographics and patterns
Discussion on restraint, drugs, and profiling risks
Toxicology and evidence contradictions
Sponsor segments (BetterHelp, Chime, Mint, Quince)
Critique of profiling and victim labeling
Case study: Delvoye Lee Baker and Duncan Patterson
Case study: John Roach and Daniel McNeavy
FBI review of files and profile refinement
Detailed analysis of the first killer's profile
Detailed analysis of the second killer's profile
Herbert Bowmeister and Fox Hollow Farm connection
Bowmeister's death and unresolved questions
Conclusion and Hidden Brain podcast promo
More from True Crime Garage
Listen ad-free on Castria