Fox Hollow Farm /// Part 2 /// 950
Summary
Hosts Nick and Captain discuss the case of Herbert "Herb" Bowmeister, a serial killer who targeted gay men in Indianapolis. They detail how private investigator Virgil Vandegrift and detective Mary Wilson connected missing persons cases to Bowmeister’s Fox Hollow Farm. The episode covers victim Tony Harris’s dangerous encounter with Bowmeister and the eventual discovery of remains on the property. It concludes with Bowmeister’s suicide in Canada and the ongoing efforts to identify victims.
Topics discussed
Uber Eats sponsorship and back-to-school deals
Show intro, host banter, and listener shoutouts
Herbert Bowmeister's MO and the Fox Hollow Farm
Private investigator Virgil Vandergift begins search
Pattern of missing gay men and police distrust
Tony's undercover encounter with Brian Smart
Commercial break: Old Navy, HomeSense, and more
Tony reports to police and identifies the suspect
Detective Mary Wilson investigates Bowmeister
Interrogation, divorce, and discovery of remains
Bowmeister flees to Canada and commits suicide
Connecting the farm murders to I-70 Strangler cases
Victim profiles and the ongoing investigation
Outro, YouTube promotion, and SimpliSafe ad
Listen ad-free on Castria