This American Life This American Life

506: Secret Identity

Oct 26, 2026 · 1h 2m

Summary

This episode explores the concept of secret identities through three distinct stories. First, a reporter discovers the hidden machinery and the human operator behind the Paul Bunyan statue at the Trees of Mystery attraction. Second, John Ronson recounts the case of a man with delusional disorder who convinced a 21-year-old to commit bank robberies under the false pretense of a CIA operation.

Topics discussed

Intro and Life Partners promo Kids interacting with the Paul Bunyan statue Touring the inside of the Paul Bunyan statue Reflections on secret identities and spies Sponsor message from Capella University Act 1: The concept of secret identities The story of Hurston Torres, a failed bank robber Hurston's claim of being recruited by the CIA Details of the fake bank robbery operation The failed robberies and police involvement The fake CIA agent and police skepticism Josh Brady's arrest and charges Diagnosis of delusional disorder Emily's story: living with a husband's delusion Emily describes the chaos of her marriage Subtypes of delusional disorder Emily's experiences with public accusations Emily's confusion and self-doubt Treatment challenges and the delusion's persistence Josh Brady's re-arrest and conclusion of Act 1 Sponsor messages and break Act 2: Introduction to Navy, the school mascot Navy's childhood obsession with dogs Navy's discovery of mascots in second grade Parental concerns about mascot participation Navy's first appearance at a high school game The family's reaction to Navy's performance Navy becomes the official high school mascot Navy's unique dancing abilities in costume Navy's interactions with the wolf mascot Navy's transformation and confidence in costume Demonstrating the costume's effect on movement Discussion on the source of Navy's confidence Conclusion of Navy's story and producer credit Act 3: Introduction to the Juarez bus murders The second bus driver murder Victims' statement on sexual violence and revenge The rise in female murders in Juarez Police inaction and victim-blaming Public reaction to the 'Diana' killings Laura's perspective on justice and self-defense Laura's family and the decision not to report The failure of the legal system for victims Confession and retraction by a suspect Bus drivers' fear and precautions Riding the buses in Juarez The final words of the second victim and Diana's identity The statue of Diana the Hunter in Juarez Production credits Life Partners promotion and thanks Outro and preview of next week's show Preview of 'Persuasion' episode Sponsor message from LinkedIn Ads

More from This American Life

902: The Missing Minutes
Nov 16, 2026
901: Is Your Blue My Blue?
Nov 9, 2026
900: Talk Me Into It
Nov 2, 2026
489: No Coincidence, No Story!
Oct 19, 2026
427: Original Recipe
Oct 12, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria