427: Original Recipe
Summary
This episode investigates the myth of Coca-Cola’s secret formula, tracing a 1979 newspaper clipping that allegedly contains the original recipe. The host verifies the document against archives and collaborates with soda experts to recreate the drink, finding it surprisingly close to modern Coke despite lacking its signature "bite." The show also features a second story about John Resnikoff, a document dealer whose career was derailed by a massive scandal involving forged JFK and Marilyn Monroe papers.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Charles Schwab Financial Decoder
Introduction: The secret Coca-Cola formula
The myth of the 7X formula and Coke's marketing
Discovery of the recipe in a 1979 newspaper clipping
Verifying the recipe against Coke's archives
Sponsors: Capella University and AT&T
Reading the ingredients of the original formula
History of coca leaf and the removal of cocaine
Sourcing ingredients to recreate the drink
First taste test: Medicine-like flavor profile
Adjusting the recipe with modern flavor experts
Blind taste tests in the lab and supermarket
Coca-Cola archivist's reaction to the replica
Sponsors: Capella University and Squarespace
Act 2 Intro: The JFK papers and handwriting analysis
John's background as a handwriting expert
Meeting Lex Cusack and his claimed military service
Discovery of the JFK and Marilyn Monroe documents
Expert validation and the initial sales strategy
Selling the archive to investors and journalists
ABC's investigation reveals anachronisms in the documents
The 20/20 broadcast and Lex's on-air denial
Grand jury investigation and John's paranoia
Lex's confession and recantation to John
John's decision to secretly record Lex
Analysis of the recorded conversation and Lex's lies
The FBI confirms Lex never served in the military
John's lingering doubts about the forgery's origin
Credits and production acknowledgments
Outro and sign-off
Listen ad-free on Castria