373: I ENCOUNTERED A SKINWALKER IN THE WOODS | 8 TERRIFYING True Scary Stories | EP 357
Nov 17, 2026 · 1h 46m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode features a Navajo elder recounting the mysterious disappearance and strange injuries of a nine-year-old girl, which some community members attribute to a skinwalker rather than a human attacker. The narrative shifts to a Canadian firefighter who discovers a man impersonating a captive female lookout during a forest evacuation, revealing a horrific kidnapping. The transcript concludes with the beginning of a historical tale about a young man who becomes a bounty hunter in the American Southwest to pursue a notorious bandit.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Progressive Insurance
Introduction: Grandpa Tom and the Navajo Nation
The importance of storytelling and memory
Nasha's disappearance and rescue
Medical examination of Nasha's injuries
Analysis of torture methods and anomalies
Investigation of Nasha's eye infection
Searching the woods for clues
Memory gaps and police investigation
The hollow and the elder's warning
The fire and the girl's transformation
Skinwalkers: myths and realities
Grandpa Tom's personal beliefs on skinwalkers
Transition: The Kootenays and forest fires
Dry lightning and the start of the fire
Spotting smoke and helicopter deployment
Rescuing the trapped lookout
The lookout's strange behavior and lies
Interrogating the lookout about his belongings
The lookout's fabricated stories
Confronting the lookout's fear
The rescued woman's condition
Reflections on the uncaptured perpetrator
Sponsor: BetterHelp
Grandpa Bill's career in bounty hunting
Searching for work in New Mexico
Meeting Broke Nose Jack McNally
Getting hired and first bounty
The bounty on Slim Sosi
Failed attempts to capture Sosi
The Twin Lakes robbery clue
Approaching the cave hideout
Ascending the steep hill
Encounter with the giant wolf
Retrieving Slim Sosi's head
Lessons from the final hunt
Life as a reservation cop
Challenges in transferring custody
Policing as a calling
The Wheatfield murders case begins
Discovery of the four victims
Initial theories: animal attack
Expert analysis by Brian
Analysis of footprints and bipedal movement
Deeper analysis of the tracks
The missing heart and expert confusion
Discovery of unknown human DNA
Link to previous assault suspects
Case goes cold
Sponsor: K-Pause
Sponsor: K-Pause (continued)
Return to Montana and failure
Mother's job and the lookout vacancy
Accepting the lookout position
Helicopter arrival at the tower
Adjusting to life in the tower
Wildlife in the area
Ranger Hank's visit and rabbit discovery
Discovery of barefoot prints
Hank offers a gun
Refusing the gun and rationalizing
Discovery of organ meat pile
Identification of the meat
Decision to stay and defend
Preparing the .22 rifle
Moving to sleep in the tower
Hearing metallic sounds at night
Footsteps on the metal stairs
Confronting the intruder
The intruder retreats
Reflections on fear and stupidity
Later assignments and the Cascades
Daily life in the Cascades
Discovery of the bone pit
Examining the human bones
Reporting the discovery
Lab results: bones not human
Internal handling and lack of answers
Doubting the official narrative
Destruction of evidence
Ongoing pursuit of the truth
Sponsor: Zolaire
Sponsor: Coca-Cola and Underdog
More from The Lets Read Podcast
Listen ad-free on Castria