372: MY FAMILY KEPT A DARK SECRET FROM ME | 8 TERRIFYING True Scary Stories | EP 357
Nov 10, 2026 · 1h 52m
Summary
This episode features a collection of personal narratives exploring dark family histories and local legends. One speaker recounts how their family’s wealth stems from ancestors who massacred the Pomo Indians, leading to modern-day vandalism. Another shares a chilling tale of a miner who, after surviving a cave-in, attempted to blow up his mine with explosives. A third narrator reveals their lineage to the infamous Madame LaLaurie, a slave owner known for extreme cruelty in New Orleans.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Progressive Insurance
Family targeted by mysterious vandalism and threats
Ancestral history: The Pomo massacre and family curse
Reflection on family wealth and the Bloody Island Massacre
Mining accident and the haunting of Bobby Ray Miller
Sponsor: Vinted
Genealogy research: The LaLaurie mansion and slavery
Hiking horror: Encounter with a deformed man in the woods
Sponsor: K-Pos Gut Health
Family mystery: Grandfather's unexplained wealth and murders
Camping encounter with 'Hatchet Man' on the Appalachian Trail
Historical tale: John Stratton and the stoning of his son
Sponsor: Mint Mobile
WWII veteran Lemuel and the mysterious armored convoy
Outro and channel promotion
Sponsor: Hotels.com
Listen ad-free on Castria