Episode 372
Jason Schreiner Murder Longmont
Oct 19, 2026 · 54m
More True Crime podcasts · More History podcasts
Summary
This episode details the 2021 murder of mail carrier Jason Schreiner, who was shot on his route in Longmont, Colorado. The investigation reveals a complex web of relationships involving his ex-girlfriend, Devin Schreiner, and her sister, Rosa, who was living with Jason. Evidence, including a selfie and GPS data, points to Devin as the shooter, motivated by a bitter custody battle and resentment over Jason’s relationship with her sister. Both Devin and her boyfriend, Andrew Ritchie, were convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Topics discussed
Introduction and the morning of the shooting
The shooting and 911 calls from witnesses
Paramedics attempt to save Jason Schaefer
Witnesses describe the shooter fleeing the scene
Investigating workplace conflicts and a fired employee
Shifting focus to personal motives and custody battles
Interviewing AJ Richie and his wife/attorney
Rosa's testimony on the sisters' complex relationships
Rosa's fears regarding AJ and access to guns
Devin Schreiner's phone call and arrival at police
The history of conflict between Devin and Rosa
Devin's employment issues and post office intrusion
Devin's interrogation regarding her son's custody
Detective reveals evidence of Devin's presence at scene
Confronting Devin with the scanner and car evidence
The incriminating selfie and physical description match
Devin's final statements and refusal to confess
Arrest of Devin Schreiner for first-degree murder
Arrest of Andrew Ritchie for complicity in murder
Jail phone call and the defense of coercion
Verdict, sentencing, and the aftermath for the child
More from Sword and Scale
Listen ad-free on Castria