Sword and Scale Sword and Scale

Episode 376

David Cole Murder Zanesville Ohio

Nov 10, 2026 · 1h 11m

Summary

In this episode, Detective Brian Ruff details the investigation into the death of 80-year-old David Cole Sr. in Zanesville, Ohio, whose body was found in a shed after his family claimed he had moved away. The case unravels as a 16-year-old girl reports the truth, revealing that his daughter-in-law, Brittany, overdosed him with sedatives on Christmas Eve to secure his Social Security benefits. The episode covers the family's attempts to hide the body for weeks, the conflicting stories told to police, and the eventual confession of murder driven by financial motive.

Topics discussed

Intro and store clearance announcement Sponsor: Direct Support Careers Interview with Nina: Family dynamics and Grandpa's move Interview with Brittany: Discrepancies in Grandpa's departure Contradictory accounts of Grandpa's location and health Tip-off: Grandpa is dead in the shed Sponsors: Direct Support and Kewpie Mayo Investigating the anonymous tip and family conflicts Police response and initial skepticism of the call Discovery of the body in the shed Phone extraction and initial shifting stories Nina's confession to spreading the rumor Interrogating Brittany: The 'natural causes' claim David's grief and the family's financial dependence Blaming David for moving the body The family's income from Grandpa's Social Security Timeline of the Orlando trip and Grandpa's death Contradictions in who found the body and when Camera footage reveals the body was there for weeks David's reaction to finding the decomposing body David's horror movie moment and moving the body Brittany admits to moving the body herself Interrogation on medication: Z-Quil and Codeine The lethal combination of Tylenol and Codeine Confession to overdosing Grandpa Sponsors: Direct Support and Kewpie Mayo Revised timeline: Death on Christmas Eve The motive: Money How the family spent the $120,000 inheritance Financial motive: Avoiding nursing home costs Toxicology results: No drugs found in blood Detective's confidence in conviction despite results Video evidence proving David's innocence Theorizing on the lack of a premeditated plan Speculation on the suddenness of the murder David's dilemma and fear of losing his sister David's plea deal and sentencing Outcome for Nina and her boyfriend David's personal history and loss of his mother Conclusion: Grandpa's tragic end Outro and final sponsor: Direct Support

More from Sword and Scale

Episode 377
Nov 15, 2026
Episode 375
Nov 8, 2026
Episode 374
Nov 2, 2026
Episode 372
Oct 19, 2026
Episode 366
Aug 23, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria