Swindled Swindled

Free Bonus: The Doppelgänger (Matthew D. Keirans)

Jul 16, 2026 · 34m

Summary

This episode details the bizarre identity theft case of Matthew Kierens, who assumed the name William Donald Woods for decades. The real Woods, homeless in Los Angeles, was arrested and imprisoned for crimes committed by Kierens, who lived a successful life in Wisconsin. A university detective eventually uncovered the truth through DNA testing, leading to Kierens' conviction and Woods' exoneration.

Topics discussed

Intro and Fousey's clip of helping a homeless man Fousey meets Bill and plans a help series Bill's backstory: abuse and early life The 'Fastest Weenie Man' and first robbery Life in San Diego and move to LA Fousey questions Bill's sanity and stories Bill disappears after motel payment issue Sponsor: Blueland cleaning products Bill discovers $200k in debt on credit report Bank visit reveals a second William Woods Arrest and court proceedings in California Institutionalization and no-contest plea Bill's continued fight to reclaim identity Detective Mallory investigates the discrepancy Sponsor: Gusto payroll software Mallory finds evidence linking Bill to father DNA test confirms Bill is the real William Woods True identity of the imposter: Matthew Kearrens Kearrens' life as William Woods in Wisconsin Sponsor: Zenni glasses Arrest and confession of Matthew Kearrens Charges and guilty plea for Kearrens Sentencing and aftermath for both men Current status of William Woods Outro and listener messages
Listen ad-free on Castria