Rerun: The Creamery (Blue Bell)
Sep 24, 2026 · 48m
More True Crime podcasts · More History podcasts
Summary
This episode details two major Listeria outbreaks linked to ice cream, focusing on the Big Olaf Creamery incident in Florida and the 2015 Blue Bell crisis in Texas. It recounts the tragic health consequences for victims, including a miscarriage and severe brain damage, while highlighting the companies' delayed recalls and defiant public responses. The narrative culminates in the criminal prosecution of Blue Bell’s former CEO, Paul Kruse, for fraud and conspiracy, which ended in a mistrial after a deadlocked jury.
Topics discussed
Holiday outfits and cozy family moments
Sponsor: OrderlyMeds GLP-1 treatments
Big Olaf Creamery Listeria outbreak details
Big Olaf's refusal to recall and legal liability
Teaser: Executive trial for Listeria negligence
Sponsor: SimpliSafe home security
Sponsors: SimpliSafe and GSK Shingles
Blue Bell history and E.F. Krusey's leadership
Paul Kruse joins Blue Bell and expands sales
2015 Listeria discovery and initial deaths
Blue Bell shutdown and public backlash
Case study: David Shockley's severe infection
Full product recall and CEO apology
Community support and viral 'Blue Bell' memes
Blue Bell promises no layoffs during cleanup
Sponsors: SimpliSafe and GSK Shingles
Layoffs and contamination in other plants
Blue Bell's gradual return to shelves
Investigation into sanitation failures and rainwater
Criticism of prioritizing volume over safety
DOJ investigation and comparison to PCA case
Sponsors: SimpliSafe and GSK Shingles
2017 recall and return to industry norms
Leadership change and investor settlement
Viral 'Blue Bell Licking' challenge and arrests
More arrests for licking ice cream in stores
Criminal indictment for cover-up of Listeria
Allegations of destroying test records
Paul Kruse trial and jury deliberation
Other ice cream recalls and consumer alerts
Show outro and listener shoutouts
Sponsors: GSK and OrderlyMeds
More from Swindled
Listen ad-free on Castria