Strict Scrutiny Strict Scrutiny

Sex Trafficking Lawsuits, Privacy Rights, and a Court That Can’t Keep Up

Oct 19, 2026 · 1h 33m

Summary

Hosts Leah Litman, Alyssa Murray, and Kate Shaw discuss the Trump administration's escalating political attacks, including the DOJ's investigation of Rep. Ilhan Omar and the firing of Ambassador Kimberly Guilfoyle. The episode recaps recent Supreme Court oral arguments on federal sentencing guidelines and the Video Privacy Protection Act, while also featuring a conversation with Alice Ollstein about her new book on the health impacts of abortion bans.

Topics discussed

Texas Ten Commandments law and CrookedCon lineup Historical quote on women's rights and episode preview Week in review: light holiday week and upcoming segments Nomination of Todd Blanche as Attorney General Katie Zechariah's first press conference as White House Press Secretary Critique of Katie Zechariah's performance and stage directions Retrospective on Katie Zechariah and legal terminology debate Discussion on legal advice vs. analysis and administration lawlessness Firing of Ambassador to Greece and impact on women's jobs Efforts to fire Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook Investigation of Ilhan Omar's financial disclosures pre-election Analysis of DOJ actions and proximity to election Sponsor: Earth Blanket and cat food discussion Sponsor: Smalls cat food promotion FCC petition review by Democratic candidates Fourth Circuit order to FCC and Justice Sauer's role Supreme Court ruling on FCC agency action timelines Supreme Court Season 8: Suncor Energy and other cases Discussion on anti-Italian discrimination and Princeton energy Beard v. United States: Case overview and sentencing guidelines Stinson v. United States and authoritative commentary Sentencing guidelines for semi-automatic firearms in Beard Appointment of amicus curiae in Beard case Imbalance at Supreme Court and amicus appointment controversy Government's position on remand and deference under Stinson Link between guidelines and commentary in sentencing calculations Oral argument: Application notes and magazine proximity Consequences of overruling Stinson for defendants Gorsuch's concerns on Booker vs. United States conflict Gorsuch's separate writing on agency deference Justices' torn stance on agency deference and judicial branch Metaphor of Jenga Tower and chaos in Supreme Court decisions Sponsor: Wild Grain bread delivery service Sponsor: Wild Grain Carbs Giving sale promotion Sponsor: Babel language learning app Sponsor: Babel discount for listeners Origin of Video Privacy Protection Act and Robert Bork Salazar v. Paramount: Case background and pixel tracking Salazar's class action and lack of consent to data sharing Sixth Circuit ruling and Supreme Court review request Oral argument: Textualist vs. literalist interpretation of VPPA Humorous exchange about film recommendations and streaming Recommendations for Supreme Court documentaries and books Textualist court principles and major questions doctrine Chief Justice Roberts' hypothetical on park signs Discussion on standing and Meta's role in the case Justice Kagan's question on standing and Suncor comparison Justices' focus on other video types and porn implications Elena Kagan's attempt to convey the porn aspect of the case Humorous commentary on justices avoiding the word 'porn' Brief transition and mention of thin mibs DOGE Service v. District Court: Grant of certiorari FOIA requests for DOGE communications and financial disclosures Supreme Court order sending dispute back to DC Circuit Constitutional questions on Musk's role and appointments clause Unitary executive theory and executive privilege implications Sponsor: Alloy menopause health platform Sponsor: Alloy discount and treatment plan details CrookedCon 2026 tickets and democracy discussion Sponsor: Hex AI analytics platform Interview with Alice Olstein: Reporting on Trump admin abortion efforts FDA review of mifepristone and environmental impact claims Political pressures on abortion access post-midterms Impact of Dobbs on general healthcare and medical practice Changes in doctor training, residency, and research due to bans Medical exceptions in abortion laws and their practical application Challenges in defining 'substantial impairment' for medical exceptions Case study: Woman denied abortion until viability due to infection risk Ambiguity in legal terms vs. medical reality for doctors Example: Woman turned away from Catholic hospital in California Impact of IVF bans on women's health and fertility Abortion bans affecting research on unrelated conditions like cancer Abandoned clinical trials due to fear of losing drug access Historical examples of drug research leading to unexpected uses Veterans and men denied medications due to abortion-related fears Impact on clinical trial enrollment for women of childbearing age Medication denials for non-pregnant individuals and children Conclusion of interview: Interconnection of abortion rights and health Favorite Things: Book recommendations and reading habits Discussion on Regency romance novels and specific titles Humorous exchange on book content and trigger warnings Recalling a Bill Pultey clip and its impact Melissa's experience at the New York Film Festival Watching The Diplomat season four premiere Leah's less glamorous activities and book recommendations Recommendation of 'Blockers' book on DOGE Promotion for Showtime's The Circus and midterm coverage Writers Guild of America East and midterm story focus Sponsor: Hex AI for data analysis and reporting Closing remark: El Salvador

More from Strict Scrutiny

Will SCOTUS Make It Harder to Sue Federal Officers?
Nov 16, 2026
The Blueprint for a Better Supreme Court
Nov 11, 2026
Will the Blue Wave Come for SCOTUS?
Nov 9, 2026
The DOJ’s Failed Attempts To Meddle In The Midterms
Nov 2, 2026
The DOJ is a Corrupt Clown Show
Oct 26, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria