Strict Scrutiny Strict Scrutiny

Will the Blue Wave Come for SCOTUS?

Nov 9, 2026 · 1h 41m

Summary

Hosts Kate Shaw, Melissa Murray, and Leah Litman celebrate the midterm election results while analyzing how the Supreme Court’s recent rulings undermined democratic processes. They discuss the oral arguments in St. Mary’s Parish v. Roy, highlighting the justices’ arguments for a constitutional right to discriminate against LGBTQ+ individuals using public funds. The episode also features a conversation with Sherilyn Ifill on the imperative for Supreme Court reform, including confirmation process changes and term limits, to restore institutional accountability.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Americans United for Separation of Church and State Sponsor: Wyndham Rewards travel program Host banter: Email signatures and political figures Celebrating the 'Blue Wave' election results Introduction to St. Mary Parish v. Roy case Game announcement: Name Your Favorite Biblical Divorcee Harmeet Dillon retirement and DOJ news White House staff changes: Susie Wiles and Stephen Miller Reaction to Miller's elevation and Democratic strategy Potential upside of Miller's policies for Democrats Sponsor: Small's Fresh Cat Food Sponsor: Mint Mobile holiday deal Sponsor: Mint Mobile disclaimer Election recap: Balancing joy and serious analysis Joke: Subpoena for Elon Musk and Pinot Grigio SCOTUS impact on gerrymandering and voter suppression Mississippi Senate race: Coleman vs. Hyde-Smith Mississippi felony disenfranchisement history Voter turnout overwhelming electoral distortions DOJ inquiry into Dobbs opinion leak Conspiracy theories: Trump, Blanche, and Alito Satirical list of future policy mandates Susan Collins concession call controversy Guest intro: Anita Earls and Abdul El-Sayed podcast Sponsor: M4 Skincare for perimenopause Sponsor: M4 Skincare discount code Sponsor: 3-Day Blinds St. Mary Parish case: Free exercise vs. non-discrimination Oral arguments: Admitting intent to discriminate Liberal justices' concerns on religious exemptions Conservative justices' lack of engagement in argument Critique of conservative justices' performance Argument on excluding schools that discriminate Legal standard: Knowledge of negative impact State position: Anti-discrimination principles Critique of logic: Stopping discrimination by allowing it Libertarian argument: 2000 schools for LGBT parents Jim Crow light analogy and Kavanaugh's argument Kavanaugh's 'bastardizing feminism' argument Title VII does not prohibit discrimination based on being dumb Colorado's position: Equal opportunity helps religious families Prediction: Depressing argument, people power wins Sponsor: Quince cashmere and winter gear Sponsor: Quince app and holiday shipping Guest intro: Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang (Las Culturistas) Guest intro: Sherrilyn Ifill, 14th Amendment Center Why Supreme Court reform is essential for accountability Electoral victories as preparation, not finality Lessons from Biden administration's inaction Broken confirmation process and 21st century needs Court limitations, ethics, and adding seats Elections as instrumental to policy implementation SCOTUS hostility to anti-corruption statutes Historical context: Lynching and sharecropping Caperton v. Massey and justice corruption Voter rejection of abusive immigration enforcement Spiritual harm of having a base leader Dismantling Voting Rights Act as rebuke of history Public education and support for reform hearings Reclaiming the term 'institutionalist' Shadow docket leaks and institutional integrity Personal respect for the Court despite disagreement Adopting 'YOLO' energy for bold reform Lessons from Reconstruction and facing danger Accountability vs. retribution in other countries Recognizing weakness vs. confrontation Game: Brainstorming ways to make justices quit Game: This or That - Georgia Governor vs. Fox News Game: This or That - Flipping seats vs. Barrett hot mic Game: This or That - Legislative wins vs. Supreme Courts Game: This or That - Hard choices for democracy Game: This or That - Senators ad vs. Protein ad Game: This or That - Unemployment vs. No face control Vogue cover: Barack, Abdul, Zoran, Ossoff Game: This or That - Earls video vs. Petty conduct Reflection on Justice Earls and margin of victory Transition to final thoughts Former Confederate states sending Democrats to Senate Game: This or That - Trump rallies vs. Cheesecake factories Personal story: Sticking around to see the end Gratitude for those who paved the way Favorite things: Barrett Adair and Stacey Abrams M. Gessen column on autocratic worldview Resources: 14th Amendment Center and Blue Wave outfits Shoutouts: Princeton Pre-Law Society and listeners Thank yous to supporters Minnesotans showing we can get through this Production credits and call to action Sponsor: Crooked Media subscription Sponsor: OxyClean Versatile Stain Remover

More from Strict Scrutiny

Will SCOTUS Make It Harder to Sue Federal Officers?
Nov 16, 2026
The Blueprint for a Better Supreme Court
Nov 11, 2026
The DOJ’s Failed Attempts To Meddle In The Midterms
Nov 2, 2026
The DOJ is a Corrupt Clown Show
Oct 26, 2026
Sex Trafficking Lawsuits, Privacy Rights, and a Court That Can’t Keep Up
Oct 19, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria