Strict Scrutiny Strict Scrutiny

Will SCOTUS Let Big Oil Off the Hook?

Oct 12, 2026 · 1h 34m

Summary

Hosts Leah Litman and Melissa Murray recap the first week of the Supreme Court term, focusing on the Suncor v. Boulder County climate case with guest Kirthi Datla of Earth Justice. They analyze the oil companies' novel constitutional arguments and the Court's apparent hostility to state tort litigation. The episode also critiques Justice Alito’s new book, "So Ordered," and his recent media appearances, highlighting his inconsistent originalist claims and controversial statements regarding abortion and judicial independence.

Topics discussed

Texas Ten Commandments law and Supreme Court challenge Crooked Con 2026 lineup and ticket promotion Episode intro and agenda: Suncor and Alito's book Suncor v. Boulder County: Case background and guest intro Oral argument recap: Constitutional theories and confusion Deconstructing the 'extraterritoriality' and 'plan of convention' arguments Critique of 'equal sovereignty' and state police powers The 'cabal' argument and preemption of state tort claims Air vs. water pollution precedents and 'wall of precedence' EPA absence and federal preemption of Clean Air Act Jurisdictional issues and the 'final judgment' off-ramp Judicial economy and the magnitude of climate damages National Pork Producers v. Ross and Dormant Commerce Clause Closing thoughts on Suncor and Justice Kagan's clip Sponsor segments: Zbiotics and Mint Mobile Justice Alito's CBS interview on abortion and Dobs Alito's 'abstract' comments on women and reality Alito on the Court's role and political neutrality Overview of Alito's book 'So Ordered' and its content Alito's defense of the shadow docket and emergency procedures Alito's admission of results-oriented originalism Alito's persecution complex and 'boldness' in judging Dissonance in Alito's views on women and racism Sponsor segments: Bookshop.org and Alloy Health Alito's interpretive methodologies and Icarian originalism Unenumerated rights and praise for non-originalist scholars Cash Patel's marriage and the Guilfoyle wire transfer scandal Analysis of the Guilfoyle financial misconduct and divorce threat Trump's attempts to remove Lisa Cook and state violence roundup Krista's failed execution and psychological trauma Sponsor segment: 3day Blinds Promotion for Crooked Con 2026 Sponsor segment: Hex AI Interview with Bernadette Atwohine on property law in Detroit Detroit property tax foreclosures and constitutional violations Case study: Grandpa Bucci vs. Grandpa Brown and racial covenants Impact of redlining and blockbusting on family wealth Alito's Italian heritage and the 'Trump v. Barbara' colloquy National property tax disparities and the 'double bind' Predatory governance and Ferguson as a case study Legal victories and settlements in Detroit property tax cases Detroit as ground zero for the reparations movement Bookshop.org promotion for 'Plundered' Listener favorites: Vladek's post and Osseff vs. Collins Marquette poll on Supreme Court expansion support Book recommendation: 'Cherry Baby' by a romance author Recap of a recent event with notable attendees Promotion for a book on Samuel Alito Vote Save America promotion Final Crooked Con 2026 promotion Final Hex AI sponsor segment

More from Strict Scrutiny

Will SCOTUS Make It Harder to Sue Federal Officers?
Nov 16, 2026
The Blueprint for a Better Supreme Court
Nov 11, 2026
Will the Blue Wave Come for SCOTUS?
Nov 9, 2026
The DOJ’s Failed Attempts To Meddle In The Midterms
Nov 2, 2026
The DOJ is a Corrupt Clown Show
Oct 26, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria