Mary Orsini
Summary
This episode details the 1982 murder of Alice MacArthur, wife of prominent Arkansas attorney Bill MacArthur. Investigators uncover that Mary Lee Orsini, an obsessive client who believed Bill was romantically interested in her, hired hitmen to kill Alice to remove her from the picture. Despite a failed pipe bomb attempt on Bill earlier, Mary Lee orchestrated the shooting, leading to her conviction for capital murder and a later deathbed confession.
Topics discussed
Introduction: The murder of Alice MacArthur
Discovery of the body and crime scene details
Alice and Bill MacArthur's background and marriage
Investigation into motives and the previous bombing attempt
Fingerprint evidence leads to hitman Yankee Hall
Hall's confession and the identification of Mary Lee Orsini
Mary Lee Orsini's background and her husband's death
Private investigator reveals Mary Lee's financial motive
Mary Lee's obsession with attorney Bill MacArthur
The failed bombing and the hiring of the shooter
The bogus tape and handwriting evidence
Arrests and the false accusation against Bill MacArthur
Trials, convictions, and Mary Lee's deathbed confession
Listen ad-free on Castria