Brenda Watson
Oct 25, 2026 · 42m
More True Crime podcasts · More News podcasts
Summary
This episode details the 2009 murder of Tommy Kellum in Lake City, Florida, whose body was found decomposing in his home while his partner, Brenda Watson, was missing. Investigators uncover evidence of their volatile relationship, including Brenda’s jealousy and Tommy’s infidelity, leading to her arrest after she attempted to flee to Canada. Brenda confesses to shooting Tommy after he rejected her marriage proposal, resulting in a second-degree murder conviction and a 30-year prison sentence.
Topics discussed
Cold open: The discovery and the shocking confession
Detectives arrive at the scene of the crime
Tommy Kellum's background and work ethic
Tommy's first marriage and infidelity
The relationship between Tommy and Brenda
Family reactions and the missing wife
Investigating the timeline and credit card records
Crime scene evidence and Brenda's lifestyle
The tip about Jeffrey Love
Interrogating Eugene, Brenda's lover
New leads: Tommy's ex-girlfriend and violence
Walmart footage identifies Brenda and a male
Identifying Jeffrey Love and tracking the suspects
Arresting Jeffrey Love and his confession
Jeffrey's account of the events and cover-up
Manhunt for Brenda in Pennsylvania
Brenda's confession and motive
Trial, verdict, and family reflection
More from Snapped: Women Who Murder
Listen ad-free on Castria