Small Town Murder Small Town Murder

The Many Marriages Murderer - Steamboat Springs, Colorado

Nov 12, 2026 · 3h 5m

Summary

Hosts James Petrogallo and Jimmy Wissman introduce a murder case in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, by detailing the town’s history, demographics, and real estate market. The episode then shifts to the 1972 murder of William Clark Coit Jr., exploring the background of his young wife, Jill, including her troubled upbringing, multiple marriages, and her relationship with Coit.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Midi hormone care for women Live show announcement and Patreon plug Show disclaimer and comedy/murder mix Introducing Steamboat Springs, Colorado Steamboat Springs history and Ute removal Town reviews and local reputation Cost of living and housing prices Local real estate listings and oddities Local music scene and bands Background on Clark Coit and missing funds Jill's early life and Louisiana roots Sponsor: BetterHelp therapy Sponsor: Fee-free cash back card Jill's youth, marriage, and first divorce Jill's second marriage and divorce Jill's third marriage and move to Texas Jill's fourth marriage and French Quarter life Clark Coit's background and personality Clark and Jill's relationship and marriage Sponsor: Quince holiday shopping Sponsor: SmileSet teeth whitening Sponsor: Small's cat food Clark's secrecy and family dynamics The Coit children and naming confusion Local car clubs and community events Rumors of Jill's affairs and infidelity Jill's jealousy and marital conflicts Jill's reputation and moral flexibility The murder weapon and caliber debate Clark's final moments and disappearance Jill's hospitalization and lack of interrogation Jill's fifth marriage to a Marine Fake pregnancy and child support scheme Jill's manipulation tactics and charm Haitian divorce and legal jurisdiction Jill's sixth marriage and stability Husbands' perspectives on Jill's charm Jill's cultural clash in Steamboat Jerry Boggs' background and hardware store Sponsor: Fume smoking cessation Jerry Boggs' military and business life Jerry's personality and community standing Jerry and Jill's relationship and marriage Secret marriage and hidden past Fake pregnancy and Jill's disappearance Investigation and Doug's private detective Jill's aliases and marital history Annulment and divorce timeline Property disputes and fake deeds Jerry's desire for a jury trial Jill's seventh marriage and name usage Civil trial and Jerry's return home Witness sighting of two suspicious people Neighbor's fear and locked doors Discovery of Jerry's body and scene details Local reaction and police investigation Police focus on Jill and Bacchus Forensic analysis of Jerry's last meal Onion evidence and hash brown discrepancy Stomach contents match the shack's food Search of Jill's room and vehicle Seth's testimony and phone call Jill's phone call and murder admission Jill's attempts to hire hitmen Jill's false accusations against Jerry Jill's manipulation of Troy Giffen Vietnam buddy code and silence Jerry's emotional vulnerability Jill's arrest and bail amount Jill's interrogation and national press Community grief and local impact Jill's self-perception and past husbands Trial venue and joint trial setup Legal teams and prosecution strategy Taped conversation and child dispute Non-disturbance agreement and Carl Steele Sons testifying against their mother Defendants' decision not to testify Juror deliberation and recollection Community sadness and Steamboat Pilot quote TV movie adaptation and Neil Patrick Harris Jill's post-conviction actions and claims Clemency denial and media interviews Final thoughts on Jill's manipulation Social media and live show promotion Patreon shoutouts and personal updates Patreon shoutouts continued Patreon shoutouts and gratitude Upcoming live show dates and closing

More from Small Town Murder

Bloody Pointless Revenge - Madison, South Dakota
Nov 21, 2026
Burning Desire For Murder - Murphys, California
Nov 19, 2026
Maniacal Revenge Massacre - Berlin, Vermont
Nov 14, 2026
The Secret Serial Killer - Bald Knob, Arkansas
Nov 7, 2026
The Widow & The Deer Hunter - Belfast, Maine
Nov 5, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria