Small Town Murder Small Town Murder

The Widow & The Deer Hunter - Belfast, Maine

Nov 5, 2026 · 3h 0m

Summary

This episode of Small Town Murder explores the 1983 murder of Mervyn "Sonny" Groton Jr. in Belfast, Maine, blending dark comedy with true crime. The hosts detail the town's history and the Groton family's tragic past, including a 1959 house fire that killed three of their children. They discuss the family's dynamics, highlighting Sonny's devoted nature and his wife Norma's alleged infidelity and volatile behavior, before recounting the night Sonny was found dead in his driveway.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Odoo all-in-one business management software Live show tickets for November in Tarrytown and Medford Promo for Crime and Sports: Nazis and LSD connection Introduction to the week in coastal Maine Local history: Naming conventions and Revolutionary War Casual chat: Home security and deadbolts Discussion on local attitudes toward newcomers Critique of Johnny Depp's accent in Donnie Brasco Local demographics: Income, cost of living, and housing Real estate tour: Barn-style homes in the woods The Weekender music festival lineup in Belfast Interview with local band Plague Dad Background on Sonny Groton: Navy career and family Sponsor: BetterHelp mental health services Sponsor: Quince luxury goods at lower prices Sonny's marriage to Norma and the birth of Russell The 1959 house fire that killed three children Investigation into the fire: Windows and rescue efforts Historical context: House fires in the mid-20th century Anecdotes about old electrical systems and safety Discussion on naming conventions: Juniors and Seconds Sonny's transfer to Newport, Rhode Island Family dynamics: Sonny's generosity vs Norma's selfishness Norma's alleged manipulation and running a con Psychological discussion: Trauma bonding and stability Norma's history of running away to California Introduction of Boyd Smith as Norma's boyfriend Sponsor: Zenni online eyewear shop Sponsor: Ladder.fit workout plans Sponsor: Ladder.fit structured workout benefits Sponsor: Smart AI security cameras The murder of Sonny Groton on December 9, 1983 Initial police response and Norma's inability to speak Ballistic analysis of the three shots fired Reconstruction: Sonny shot in the walkway from the backyard Humor segment: Confusion over NCIS acronym Lack of physical evidence: Only shell casings found Theory of an inside job: Knowledge of Sonny's routine Investigation into potential enemies and motives Local drug scene in the early 1980s Introduction to Joel Fuller: The 'Waldo County Bad Man' Joel Fuller's hobby: Painting and hunting Discussion on hunting culture and local knowledge Norma's polygraph test and suspicion of motive Investigation into financial benefits and VA claims The 1985 cocaine ring raid in Belfast Firearms examination: Inconclusive results on the rifle The hit: $20,000 and two sports cars for Joel Fuller Timeline: Joel Fuller's imprisonment and release Fuller's confession: Shooting Sonny in the back and head Norma's multiple interviews by investigators Norma's reaction to the 1959 fire and guilt Motive: Sonny's impending retirement and return to Maine Investigative strategy: Brainstorming new approaches Introduction of undercover agent Dave Truesdale Undercover operation: Agent 'Tony' approaches Norma Norma's evasive responses to the undercover agent Building a library of conversations with Norma Revelation: Norma mentions Boyd Smith's name Second meeting with Boyd Smith by the undercover agent Boyd admits to facilitating the murder conspiracy Interrogation of Boyd Smith: Pressuring for the truth Boyd's account: Norma's initial requests to kill Sonny The dry run: Boyd's failed attempt and cold feet Norma's demand: Find someone else to do it Boyd's realization of Norma's true nature Boyd connects Norma to Joel Fuller Boyd's claim of innocence and washed hands Police assessment: Boyd lacked the guts to shoot Confronting Norma: The passage of time and appearance Interrogation tactics: Presuming the confession Norma's confession: Accumulation of small grievances Norma admits to planning to kill her husband Humor segment: Confusion over NCIS acronym again Norma's justification: The children will understand Reflection on knowing one's spouse and family The 30-30 rifle found in the pond Legal issues: Statute of limitations on conspiracy Boyd Smith's defense: Pressure and lack of intent Legal argument: No duty to notify authorities Charges against Norma: Murder and theft of benefits Trial testimony: Lawrence Phillips and hearsay objections Joel Fuller takes the Fifth Amendment Norma's testimony: Insurance and benefit collection Verdict: Norma found guilty of murder Victims' statements: The impact on the family Sentencing: Life in prison with parole eligibility Witness issues: Larry Phillips smoking pot before testifying Joel Fuller found not guilty: Jury shock Undercover agent's perspective on justice served Legal analysis: Hearsay and incriminating statements Crawford v. Washington and testimonial statements Joel Fuller's denial via letters to Sheriff Ford Norma's pattern of forgiveness and return Closing thoughts on small town murder stories Promo for Crime and Sports: Harlem Globetrotters Call for listener stories: People who would never hire a killer Credits: Executive producers and staff Credits: Additional staff and contributors Upcoming tour dates and ticket information

More from Small Town Murder

Bloody Pointless Revenge - Madison, South Dakota
Nov 21, 2026
Burning Desire For Murder - Murphys, California
Nov 19, 2026
Maniacal Revenge Massacre - Berlin, Vermont
Nov 14, 2026
The Many Marriages Murderer - Steamboat Springs, Colorado
Nov 12, 2026
The Secret Serial Killer - Bald Knob, Arkansas
Nov 7, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria