Savage Murder & Strange Milkshakes - Arab, Alabama
Sep 24, 2026 · 3h 9m
More True Crime podcasts · More Comedy podcasts
Summary
Hosts James Petrigall and Jimmy Wisman explore the murder of a woman in Arab, Alabama, a town named by postal error and plagued by high crime rates. The episode details the life of Randall Pagett, who maintained a long-term affair with neighbor Judy Bagwell while married to Kathy. The story highlights Judy's obsessive behavior, including hiding in Kathy's car in disguise and collecting Randall's discarded personal items, before the case takes a dark turn involving DNA evidence and a twisted motive.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Midi menopause care
Intro: The weirdest Small Town Murder story
The town of Arab, Alabama and its name
Local demographics, businesses, and reviews
Real estate and local landmarks
Introducing Randall Paget and Kathy Shears
Judy Bagwell and her wrestling connection
Sponsors: ShipStation and Bomba
The affair between Randall and Judy
Judy's replica bedrooms and strange habits
The church parking lot confrontation
Kathy's disappearance and discovery
Crime scene investigation and destroyed evidence
Sponsors: Ladder and Zocdoc
Sponsor: Chime and Randall's alibi
Police interrogation and Judy's alibi
Randall's financial troubles and DNA testing
Arrest, bond, and the plea deal
Trial: DNA admissibility and jury selection
Conflicting DNA results and expert testimony
Sponsor: Ladder and host stress
Defense experts and witness credibility
Cross-examination of family and witnesses
Guilty verdict and sentencing phase
Sentencing: Life vs Death Penalty
Alabama's judicial override system
Life on death row and executions
Appeals and the PGM DNA discrepancy
Legal arguments on necrophilia and rape
New trial and the anti-death penalty rally
New defense attorney and the plant witness
Judge fairness and Judy's testimony prep
Judy's testimony: Obsession and alibi
Judy's testimony: The car and DNA
The 'Milkshake Lady' and semen storage
Randall's testimony and jury deadlock
Mistrial, acquittal, and release
Compensation and life after prison
Advocacy work and upcoming tour dates
Outro: Patrons and sponsors
More from Small Town Murder
Bloody Pointless Revenge - Madison, South Dakota
Nov 21, 2026
Burning Desire For Murder - Murphys, California
Nov 19, 2026
Maniacal Revenge Massacre - Berlin, Vermont
Nov 14, 2026
The Many Marriages Murderer - Steamboat Springs, Colorado
Nov 12, 2026
The Secret Serial Killer - Bald Knob, Arkansas
Nov 7, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria