Murder From The Shadows - Stab, Kentucky
Oct 1, 2026 · 3h 8m
More True Crime podcasts · More Comedy podcasts
Summary
Hosts James Petrigall and Jimmy Wisman introduce a murder case from Stab, Kentucky, a tiny town near Somerset. They discuss the local demographics, the opioid crisis, and the history of Sheriff Samuel Wilson Catron, whose father was shot by bootleggers in 1957. The episode sets the stage for a 1950s trick-or-treat murder, using the town's background and the Catron family's history as context for the upcoming story.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Midi menopause care
Intro, Patreon, and episode preview
Hosts introduction and shout-out
Location: Somerset, Kentucky
Town naming story and local lore
Local spring and water source anecdote
Summer Nights Cruises 25th anniversary
Dukes of Hazzard replica and local culture
Pop culture: Phantasm and Poltergeist actors
Local demographics and zip code
Housing affordability and local economy
Local architecture: walk-out basements
Local music scene and bands
Introduction of Sheriff Samuel Wilson Catron
Sponsor: Whatnot live shopping app
Sponsor: Fume smoking cessation
Fume sponsor call to action
Sheriff Catron's career and pensions
1957 bootlegging incident and trial
Hung jury and lack of eyewitnesses
Organized crime testimony and probation
Young Sam's vow to become a cop
Discussion on sexual orientation relevance
Youth shaping and troop rules anecdote
Predator honeypot theory
Sheriff's relationship with Johnny Adams
Political patronage and county power
Election tie and coin flip law
Federal extortion charges and corruption
Public perception of Sheriff Catron
Sponsor: Thrive Market grocery
Thrive Market product details
Sponsor: Quince clothing
Sponsor: Simply Save security
Sheriff's unmarked car and wedding photo
Farm survival and marijuana task force
Meth epidemic and Sheriff's enforcement
April 13, 2002: Fish fry event
Cake auction and Sheriff's purchase
The shooting: witness accounts
Shooter on the grassy knoll
Comparison to Lee Harvey Oswald
Sheriff holding a bunt cake
Chase and motorcycle crash
Shooter surrender and identification
Tire iron confrontation
Investigator suspects and drug arrests
Racist slurs and militia expulsion
Danny Shelley's nickname and background
Shelley's Marine service and debt
Oxycontin addiction and pain pills
Symbiotic relationship with Ken White
Ken White's physical description
White as drug dealer and informant
Doctors' claims on drug addictiveness
White's dual role and bragging
Bragging about murders in other counties
Gender dynamics and social banter
Motorcycle registration and initial interview
Phone recordings and misdirection
Dixie Mart and initial denial
Arrest evidence: camo, rifle, receipt
Jeff Morris's campaign and loan
Investigator skepticism of the plot
"Not from around these parts" culture
Morris's political disadvantages
White's campaign activities
White's emotional breakdown in interview
Morris learns White is a drug dealer
Conspiracy to kill the Sheriff
Fear of arrest as motive
Battery purchase and Xanax claim
Evidence: Walmart tape and tire iron
Charges and community shock
Congressman as spokesman and swag
Political grief and police chief name
Tributes to Sheriff Catron
Election proceeds and Catron's death
Morris plea deal dispute
Morris claims innocence in court
Steve Anderson capture and Shelley plea
Shelley's remorse and drug influence
Shelley's testimony on threats
IQ test and legal defense
White as drug lord and manipulator
Morris testimony and defense questions
Jury verdict and death penalty debate
Life without parole sentence
Public calls for hanging
Legal argument on cake delivery
White's death in prison
Congressman's view on Shelley
Shelley as second victim
Outro: Tickets and social media
Credits: Producers and locations
Credits: Additional staff
Credits: Rollo and 4-way stop
Credits: More staff names
2026 Tour dates announcement
More from Small Town Murder
Bloody Pointless Revenge - Madison, South Dakota
Nov 21, 2026
Burning Desire For Murder - Murphys, California
Nov 19, 2026
Maniacal Revenge Massacre - Berlin, Vermont
Nov 14, 2026
The Many Marriages Murderer - Steamboat Springs, Colorado
Nov 12, 2026
The Secret Serial Killer - Bald Knob, Arkansas
Nov 7, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria