Guilty Google Search Murder - Winchester, Indiana
Sep 25, 2026 · 1h 13m
More True Crime podcasts · More Comedy podcasts
Summary
Hosts James Petrigall and Jimmy Wisman discuss the 2018 murder of David Brumley in Winchester, Indiana, whose body was found with his head covered by a pillowcase and garbage bag. The episode details the investigation into his death and highlights the suspect, his neighbor Monty Cook, who had recently been released from prison after serving time for arson and a kidnapping plot. The hosts explore the bizarre circumstances surrounding Brumley’s disappearance and the local community’s reaction to the crime.
Topics discussed
Serval AI sponsorship and introduction
Live show recap and Patreon promotion
Winchester, Indiana geography and local history
Local industries, tornadoes, and town reviews
Hoosier culture and the Hawaiian Steel Guitar Festival
Victim David Brumley and his prized Mustang
Suspect Monty Cook and MasterCraft arson background
Cook's kidnapping plot and 2004 arrest
ButcherBox and Square sponsorships
Cook's 2004 trial, sentencing, and release
Discovery of Brumley's body in 2018
Investigation, DNA evidence, and person of interest
Zazzle sponsorship and BetterHelp intro
Casper mattress sponsorship
Cook's flight, online searches, and capture
Trial evidence, motive, and guilty verdict
Sentencing, appeals, and final outcome
Show conclusion and upcoming tour dates
Jerry's, OnDeck, and Guiding Stars sponsorships
More from Small Town Murder
Bloody Pointless Revenge - Madison, South Dakota
Nov 21, 2026
Burning Desire For Murder - Murphys, California
Nov 19, 2026
Maniacal Revenge Massacre - Berlin, Vermont
Nov 14, 2026
The Many Marriages Murderer - Steamboat Springs, Colorado
Nov 12, 2026
The Secret Serial Killer - Bald Knob, Arkansas
Nov 7, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria