Bloody Triple Murder Madness - El Rancho, New Mexico
Oct 30, 2026 · 1h 16m
More True Crime podcasts · More Comedy podcasts
Summary
This episode of Small Town Murder Express investigates the brutal 2011 axe murders of Lloyd and Dixie Ortiz and their adopted son Steven in El Rancho, New Mexico. Hosts James Petrogallo and Jimmy Wissman detail the victims' compassionate lives and the suspicious behavior of their daughter Cherie and son-in-law Jesse, who initially withheld critical details about a gray car fleeing the scene. The narrative explores the involvement of local teenagers and the subsequent year-long investigation that left the family under suspicion while the true killer remained unidentified.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Fanatic Sportsbook
Live show announcements and tour dates
Intro: Recent media and documentaries
Introduction to El Rancho, New Mexico
Geography and demographics of El Rancho
Local history and the Manhattan Project
Santa Fe culture and festivals
Local events and community activities
The Ortiz family: Lloyd and Dixie
Daughters Angela and Sherry
Stephen Ortiz: Disabilities and foster care
Stephen's recovery and community role
Stephen's medical marijuana and social life
Sherry's household and family dynamics
Introduction of Nicholas Ortiz
Nicholas's character and church involvement
Nicholas and Jose Roybal's friendship
Nicholas staying with the Ortiz family
Nicholas's theft and chores arrangement
Rising tensions before Father's Day
Sponsor: ShipStation
Sponsor: ShipStation continued
Sponsor: Ollie dog food
Sponsor: Ollie holiday feast details
Sponsor: Ollie closing
Analysis of Sherry's psychological state
Teenagers' reliance on church as safe space
Introduction of Ashley and Jose Roybal
Jose's alleged threats in the neighborhood
Father's Day: Sherry enters the house
Discovery of the bodies
Details of the attacks on Dixie and Stephen
Initial police investigation and lack of evidence
Sherry and Jesse's initial alibi
Jesse's claim of following a gray car
Early reports of murder-suicide theory
Scene cleanup and missing evidence
Discovery of the pickaxe weapon
Nichalus claims he did it
Police suspicion shifts to Sherry and Jesse
Financial impact on the Ortiz family
Search of Sherry and Jesse's home
Police spokesperson on investigation status
Investigation of meth and weed rumors
Ashley Roybal offers information
Inconsistencies in Ashley's story
Ashley's account of the robbery plan
Sponsor: Thrive Market
Sponsor: Thrive Market lunch ideas
Sponsor: Quince clothing
Sponsor: Quince pricing and ethics
Sponsor: SimpliSafe home security
Sponsor: SimpliSafe personal experience
Sponsor: SimpliSafe discount code
Nicholas's confession and alibi
Nicholas's entry into the house
Jose's testimony against Nicholas
Nicholas seeks prayer from pastor
Forensic analysis of handedness
Nicholas's alibi timeline
Jose's account of the night
Nicholas's statements about Stephen
Disposal of evidence and clothes
Bail hearings and release
Trial atmosphere and local bias
Defense suspicion of Sherry
Jose's undisclosed plea deal
Defense argument for not guilty
Retrial and new defense theory
Jury selection and comments
Motion for new trial denied
Sentencing arguments regarding age
Final sentence and parole eligibility
Reactions from family and community
Conclusion and final thoughts
Outro: Tour dates and Patreon
2026 Tour announcement
More from Small Town Murder
Bloody Pointless Revenge - Madison, South Dakota
Nov 21, 2026
Burning Desire For Murder - Murphys, California
Nov 19, 2026
Maniacal Revenge Massacre - Berlin, Vermont
Nov 14, 2026
The Many Marriages Murderer - Steamboat Springs, Colorado
Nov 12, 2026
The Secret Serial Killer - Bald Knob, Arkansas
Nov 7, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria