Twilight Zone Of Death - Depew, Oklahoma
Summary
Hosts James Petrigallo and Jimmy Wissman explore the 2002 Depew, Oklahoma, murders committed by Scott Eisenberg. After arriving on a bicycle claiming to raise 9/11 funds, Eisenberg ingratiates himself with locals, seduces Kathy Biggs, and isolates her from her family. The episode details his controlling behavior and the tragic events that unfold in this small, declining town.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Bombas socks and live show tickets
Intro: Small Town Murder and Love After Lockup
Depew, Oklahoma: History, demographics, and local festivals
Scott Eisenberg arrives in Depew on a bicycle
Eisenberg's abusive past and relationship with Kathy Biggs
Eisenberg's criminal history and release from custody
The murders of the Cantrell family and attack on Tyler
The massive manhunt for Scott Eisenberg
Eisenberg's capture after kidnapping the Peebles
Aftermath: Kathy Biggs' life and Eisenberg's suicide attempt
The trial, verdict, and death penalty sentencing
Eisenberg's execution and victim impact statements
Outro: Patreon shoutouts and upcoming tour dates
Listen ad-free on Castria