Small Town Murder Small Town Murder

Mystery Of The Disappearing Man - Belgrade, Montana

Oct 29, 2026 · 3h 8m

Summary

Hosts James Petragallo and Jimmy Wissman investigate the 1990 disappearance of Brad Brisbin in Belgrade, Montana, whose friend claimed he fled with a blonde woman in a red car. The episode details the town's history and real estate market before delving into Brisbin's background as a former deputy and the bizarre 1984 kidnapping of biathlete Carrie Swenson by the "Mountain Men," which involved a fatal shooting during a massive manhunt.

Topics discussed

Wayfair Holiday Decor Sponsorship Show Intro and Patreon Promotion Comedy Disclaimer and Previous Episode Recap West Yellowstone Demographics and Cost of Living Local Real Estate and Housing Market Local Events: Music and Witchcraft Activities Dating Habits and Escape Room Banter The Disappearance: Initial Witness Accounts Sponsors: Zazzle and Rocket Money Police Investigation and Wife's Report Brad Brisbane's Background and Career Brad's Later Life and Police Work The Nichols Incident and Kidnapping Plan Confession: Kidnapping for Marriage The Shooting and Blame Shifting Sponsors: Simply Safe and Fume Sponsor: HomeServe Home Warranty Details of the Shooting and Poaching Claim Public Reaction and Brad's Police Career Brad's Job Search and Larry Moore Intro Larry Moore's Background and Rumors The Camper and Restraining Order The Day of Disappearance: Phone Call Unaccounted Time and Missing Person Report Witness Accounts: Hitchhiking vs Death Larry's Changing Stories to Police Sponsor: Thrive Market Forensic Evidence: Camper Cleaning Oddities Ballistics and Blood Stain Analysis Deer Meat and Blood Origin Disputes Crime Scene Investigation with Lasers Miranda Rights and Montana Law Banter Rats in the Car and Gun Misfires Larry's Statement on Self-Harm The Blonde Woman Theory Larry's Story: Breakfast and the Truck The Bloody Man and the Sports Car Cleaning the Camper and Missing First Aid Kit Community Suspicion and Scapegoating Bail and the No Body No Crime Problem Logical Fallacies in the Case The Manhunt for Brad's Body Gravel Pit Searches and Dog Sniffing Legal Challenges and Evidence Suppression Anonymous Letters Claiming Brad is Alive Analysis of the Forged Letters DNA Fingerprinting Methodology DNA Testing Process and Results DNA Lab Errors and Gel Issues Brain Tissue DNA Extraction Challenges to DNA Science and Typewriter Court Rulings on Suppressed Evidence Media Saturation in Gallatin County DNA Statistics and Defense Objections Dr. Blake's PCR Contamination Test Defense Theory: No Body, No Crime Religious Turn and AA Testimony Juror Taint: Tina Colston Incident Larry's Alibi and Phone Call Timing Larry's Lies and Blood Origin Changes Reenactment and Closing Arguments Verdict: First DNA Conviction in Montana Juror Bias and Mourning Garb Sentencing: 110 Years Without Parole Prison Council and Warden Dinner Scandal Warden's Romance with Inmate Prison Violence and Bomb Charges Deal Brad's Body Found and Prison Conditions Family Statements on Parole Conclusion and Call to Action Credits and Staff Updates Patron Names and Spelling Corrections More Patron Names and Thanks Sponsor: Orderly Meds and Outro

More from Small Town Murder

Bloody Pointless Revenge - Madison, South Dakota
Nov 21, 2026
Burning Desire For Murder - Murphys, California
Nov 19, 2026
Maniacal Revenge Massacre - Berlin, Vermont
Nov 14, 2026
The Many Marriages Murderer - Steamboat Springs, Colorado
Nov 12, 2026
The Secret Serial Killer - Bald Knob, Arkansas
Nov 7, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria