Small Town Murder Small Town Murder

A Web Of Deceit, Sex & Murder - Keeling, Virginia

Sep 17, 2026 · 3h 3m

Summary

This episode of Small Town Murder investigates a 2002 double homicide in Keeling, Virginia, where Julian Lewis and his stepson CJ were found shot to death in their trailer. The hosts detail the victims' lives, focusing on Julian’s grief after his wife’s death and his subsequent relationship with Teresa Lewis, a woman with a troubled history and low IQ. The narrative explores the family’s dynamics, including Julian’s daughter Kathy’s hostility toward Teresa and her brother Jason’s claim that Teresa made sexual advances toward him.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Bombas socks and underwear Show intro and Patreon promotion Show format and ethical guidelines Location: Keeling, Virginia Town reviews and local crime stats Local businesses and demographics Real estate and local events Local music scene and bands Setting the scene: October 2002 Discovery of Julian Lewis The locked dog and initial investigation Sponsor: Weighted stress toy Sponsor: Smalls cat food Teresa Lewis background and family Julian Lewis background and marriages Julian's mental state and daughter Kathy Teresa and Kathy's relationship dynamics Julian's life insurance and death CJ Lewis and his insurance policy Teresa's initial police statement Autopsy results and injuries Sponsor: BetterHelp therapy Sponsor: Rocket Money finance app Julian's last lunch and death timing Missing shell casings evidence Teresa collects Julian's paycheck Teresa calls boss again next day Request for CJ's personal effects Forged signature and funeral prep Behavior at the memorial service Police doubts about Teresa's story Lunch bag discrepancy revealed Teresa admits to Matthew's involvement Teresa's confession details Rodney Fuller named as accomplice Teresa's past and drug use Matthew Schallenberger's background Schallenberger's mob connections Teresa's manipulation of the men Sponsor: SimplySafe home security Teresa invites men to her home Inappropriate behavior with daughter Purchase of murder weapons Failed ambush due to traffic Teresa's hesitation and daughter's role The night of the murders Aftermath and 911 call Arrest and evidence recovery Charges against the defendants Testimony from accomplices Sentencing of Schallenberger and Fuller Fuller's post-sentence behavior Teresa's legal strategy and plea Prosecutor's threats regarding daughter Teresa pleads guilty to avoid death Debate on Teresa's competency Planning details and funeral timing Defense argument against death penalty Lack of prior violent history Episode title and timeline summary Teresa's prison location Schallenberger's plea deal strategy Schallenberger's letters and motives Christy Bean's role and sentencing Defense argument for Christy Bean Christy Bean's final sentence Sentence suspension and relief Appeals and proportionality arguments Lack of remorse and initial denial Post-conviction appeals for Teresa Expert testimony on addiction State's rebuttal on mental state Strategic risks of addiction defense Teresa's emotional breakdown in prison Definition of intellectual disability IQ tests and conspiracy capability Legal precedents for commutation Teresa's statement to the governor Execution of Teresa Lewis Burials and Fuller's prison record Reflections on the case's weirdness Patreon shoutouts and birthdays Patreon supporter names Closing thanks and social media Sponsor: Wayfair Halloween decor

More from Small Town Murder

Bloody Pointless Revenge - Madison, South Dakota
Nov 21, 2026
Burning Desire For Murder - Murphys, California
Nov 19, 2026
Maniacal Revenge Massacre - Berlin, Vermont
Nov 14, 2026
The Many Marriages Murderer - Steamboat Springs, Colorado
Nov 12, 2026
The Secret Serial Killer - Bald Knob, Arkansas
Nov 7, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria