Science Vs Science Vs

How Hard Is It to Get Off Antidepressants?

Nov 19, 2026 · 47m

Summary

Host Wendy Zuckerman and guest Noam Hassenfeld explore the science of antidepressant withdrawal, debating whether severe symptoms are common or rare. They examine conflicting data from short-term clinical trials versus long-term user surveys, highlighting the risks of relapse versus withdrawal. The episode features insights from psychiatrists and researchers on the unknown mechanisms of SSRIs, the importance of slow tapering, and the difficulty in distinguishing between returning depression and chemical dependence.

Topics discussed

Intro: The debate on antidepressant withdrawal Dr. Mark Horowitz's personal experience with withdrawal The conflict: Clinical data vs. patient reports How antidepressants actually work (and don't) Reasons to stop: Side effects and the 'cast' analogy Reviewing the science: RCTs and common symptoms The '3% severe' claim and industry funding criticism Duration matters: Long-term users face worse withdrawal Criticisms of the long-term study and placebo effects Synthesis: Balancing the risks and unknowns Relapse rates: What happens when you stop? Relapse vs. Withdrawal: The core diagnostic dilemma Stress-testing symptoms to distinguish relapse from withdrawal Safe tapering strategies and high-risk medications Conclusion: Be curious before being certain

More from Science Vs

Is the ‘War on Science’ Over?
Nov 12, 2026
How Music Can Be Medicine, with Dr. Dan Levitin
Nov 5, 2026
Sitting: As Bad As Smoking?!
Oct 29, 2026
Testosterone: Do We All Need a Boost?
Oct 22, 2026
Fiber Maxxing and Poo Maxxing, with Dr. Trisha Pasricha
Oct 15, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria