Hunted
Laura Mcnaughton Murder Clovis New Mexico
Nov 17, 2026 · 1h 21m
More True Crime podcasts · More News podcasts
Summary
This Dateline episode investigates the 2005 murder of Laura McNaughton, a young mother found naked in a field in Clovis, New Mexico. Investigators initially focused on her bitter ex-husband, a popular radio host, and a new boyfriend who had blood in his truck, but both were cleared after polygraph tests and lab results. The story follows the family’s grief and the community’s shock as police struggle to identify the calculated killer who left the victim displayed in plain sight.
Topics discussed
Intro: Heart podcast and Dateline teaser
Discovery of a displayed body in Clovis
Pheasant hunters find the victim
Initial scene investigation and victim description
Major Crimes Unit and DA Matt Chandler's recognition
Identifying the victim as Laura McNaughton
Laura's family background and relationship with Jeff
Laura's life in Clovis and divorce from Jeff
Family travels to Clovis for the investigation
Search of Laura's home and cause of death
Questioning the hunters and analyzing the scene
Investigating the ex-husband Jeff McNaughton
Jeff's radio career and public comments on divorce
Jeff's alibi and polygraph results
Investigating Joel Delaney, the railroad worker
Joel's suspicious behavior and blood in his truck
Joel cleared and community fear persists
Joel's interview and polygraph refusal
Blood evidence in Joel's truck and final clearance
Jeff's polygraph and relief for the family
Laura's funeral and the mysterious Friday customer
Investigating the obsessed restaurant customer
Door-to-door search for the suspect
Breakthrough: A dentist calls the police
Interviewing James Smith, the dentist
Laura's warnings about the dentist's flirting
Search of Smith's spotless truck and map pocket
Blood evidence in Smith's truck and polygraph setup
Smith's self-inflicted stab wounds and note
Search of Smith's office: posters and box
Discovery of necrophilic videos and confession
Smith's arrest and initial statements
Smith's account of the night and the murder
Disposal of the body and community relief
Indictment and the 'wolf in sheep's clothing'
Defense strategy and past crimes in Oklahoma
Death penalty eligibility and plea deal negotiations
Plea hearing and sentencing to life plus 27 years
Family healing and memorializing Laura
Outro and sponsor reads
More from Dateline NBC
Listen ad-free on Castria