Talking Dateline: Hunted
Nov 18, 2026 · 25m
More True Crime podcasts · More News podcasts
Summary
Blaine Alexander discusses the Dateline episode "Hunted," which investigates the 2005 murder of Laura McNaughton in Clovis, New Mexico. The story details how local dentist James Smith, who had a disturbing obsession with corpses, killed and displayed McNaughton’s body. The episode features interviews with the pheasant hunters who found the victim, her close-knit family, and investigators, alongside a podcast-exclusive clip from Smith’s prison deposition.
Topics discussed
Introduction and episode overview
Recap of Laura McNaughton's murder and investigation
Interview with the pheasant hunters who found the body
Discussion on the body's placement and lack of concealment
Impact on the victim's close-knit family and the drive to Clovis
Humorous tangent about the victim's appearance and Hilary Duff poster
Clearing the ex-husband and reading suspect reactions
Revealing the killer's disturbing habits and dental profession
Pattern of dentist crimes and potential prior victims
Audio clip from the killer's deposition and his defense
Answering listener questions on assault, plea deal, and custody
Lighter note on morning commutes and closing remarks
More from Dateline NBC
Listen ad-free on Castria