Dark Histories Dark Histories

Earle Nelson: The Dark Strangler

Nov 17, 2026 · 1h 37m

Summary

Host Ben presents the story of Earl Nelson, known as the Dark Strangler, who terrorized California and Oregon in the 1920s. The episode details his methodical murders of elderly landladies, who he strangled and sexually assaulted after death while posing as a prospective tenant. It explores the widespread public panic, the press's sensationalism, and the police's struggle to identify the killer across state lines.

Topics discussed

Sponsorship and host introduction Show intro and Christmas Campfire announcement 1920s America: cars, jazz, and rising crime The murder of Clara Merton in San Francisco The murder of Laura Beale and public panic The murder of Lillian St Mary and the 'Dark Strangler' nickname The murder of Ollie Franey and the failed manhunt The murder of Stephen Nisbet's wife and Isabel Gallagos The false arrest of a suspect and the death of Beatrice Withers The Portland murders and the killer crossing state lines Further murders in Portland and the escape of the suspect Sponsorship break for Quince The murder of Florence Monks and the identification of the killer The Dark Strangler's spree in Kansas and Illinois The murders in Winnipeg, Canada The Winnipeg manhunt and the capture of Virgil Wilson The escape and recapture of Earl Nelson Earl Nelson's childhood and early life in San Francisco Nelson's mental health struggles and marriage to Mary The trial, insanity plea, and execution of Earl Nelson Host reflection on victims and closing remarks

More from Dark Histories

Mob Football, Murder & The Possession of Anne Gunter
Oct 27, 2026
The Strange Disappearance of Rudolf Diesel
Oct 12, 2026
Philip: The Ghost That Never Was
Sep 21, 2026
The Willie Starchfield Murder Mystery
Sep 8, 2026
Early America & The Savage Crimes of the Harpe Brothers
Aug 25, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria