Dark Histories Dark Histories

Mob Football, Murder & The Possession of Anne Gunter

Oct 27, 2026 · 55m

Summary

This episode recounts the 1604 case of Anne Gunther, who claimed to be bewitched by local women to help her father, Brian, settle a grudge stemming from a violent medieval football match. Despite initial support from physicians and clergy, the case unraveled when the Bishop of Salisbury and King James I investigated, revealing that Anne was feigning her symptoms based on a pamphlet about the Warboys witches. The story concludes with Anne’s confession to the King and the subsequent prosecution of the Gunther family in the Star Chamber.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Vinted Sponsor: Pfizer Introduction to Dark Histories History of ancient and medieval football Violence and rules of mob football Life in North Morton and the Gunters The 1598 football match and deaths Inquest and Anne Gunter's first illness Diagnosis of wandering womb and hysteria Rumors of witchcraft and folk healers Role of cunning folk and Brian's promotion Anne names three women as witches Evidence gathering and folk remedies Further healers and Brian's neck incident Alice Kerfoot's illness and arrests Sponsor: Quince Oxford academics examine Anne Thomas Hinton's skepticism Prosecution challenges and pre-trial interviews The trial at the Assizes Bishop of Salisbury investigates Anne Anne's confession to the Bishop King James investigates and Anne confesses Star Chamber trial and aftermath Sponsor: Sustain Pro Host discussion on the story and characters Outro and Patreon promotion

More from Dark Histories

Earle Nelson: The Dark Strangler
Nov 17, 2026
The Strange Disappearance of Rudolf Diesel
Oct 12, 2026
Philip: The Ghost That Never Was
Sep 21, 2026
The Willie Starchfield Murder Mystery
Sep 8, 2026
Early America & The Savage Crimes of the Harpe Brothers
Aug 25, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria