UPDATE: The Sodder Children
Sep 7, 2026 · 31m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
Crime Junkie revisits the 1945 Sauter children cold case with great-great-granddaughter Miranda Weeks, who has uncovered unpublished records and new evidence. The episode details the suspicious circumstances of the house fire, including the absence of human remains, a severed phone line, and a fire chief who buried a beef liver while claiming to have found a heart. Miranda’s research implicates local power broker Fiorenzo Genutulo, who received the insurance payout and had a personal grudge against the family, suggesting the children were kidnapped rather than killed.
Topics discussed
Show intro and Chameleon podcast plug
Introduction to the Sauter case update
Christmas Eve 1945: The night of the fire
The fire breaks out and family attempts rescue
Delayed response and the missing ladder
No remains found and site filled in
Coroner's ruling and family's doubts
Sponsor reads and the mystery caller
The man who cut the phone line
Stolen equipment and the mystery woman
Jenny's experiments and the fire chief's claim
The beef liver discovery and sponsor ads
The liver vanishes and funeral home connection
1949 excavation finds human vertebrae
Fire investigator analysis of the burn
Theories on where the kids went
Fiorenzo Genutulo and the insurance motive
The biased jury and local conspiracy
Why the parents are not suspects
Call for tips and show outro
More from Crime Junkie
Listen ad-free on Castria