Crime Junkie Crime Junkie

MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Heather Turner Part 2

Nov 2, 2026 · 1h 3m

Summary

This episode investigates the 2017 death of Heather Turner, whose husband claimed she committed suicide after an alleged affair. The hosts examine physical evidence, including blood spatter and a disputed second wound, alongside a funeral home director’s testimony that contradicts the official narrative. They also analyze Andy Turner’s memoir and a 2026 press conference where the sheriff’s office closed the case as a suicide, despite ongoing skepticism from Heather’s family and the coroner.

Topics discussed

Sponsors and show introduction Heather's plans to leave and the night of the shooting Documentary revelations and local speculation Physical evidence: blood spatter and the towel Inconsistencies in Andy's account of the night Heather's emails and plans with Rob The goodbye note and its context Andy's book and the bathroom wall theory Blood spatter on both hands and grip theory Forensic details: muzzle burns and stippling Funeral home director's observations of wounds The mystery of the second wound and coroner's report Debating entry vs. exit wound trajectories Andy and his father's behavior at the funeral Sponsor break: SimpliSafe Analysis of Andy's 911 call timeline Rumors about the former sheriff's involvement Investigating the 'I did it' audio claim Andy's book: narrative and inconsistencies Missing evidence: Andy's clothes and samples Andy's defense against abuse allegations The need for a complete record of the case Sheriff Henson's review and conclusion Sheriff's office findings on the 911 call Forensic analysis of the bathroom wall Blood patterns and the note of intent Addressing muzzle burn and sheriff rumors Coroner Lindsay Fuller's perspective Sponsor break: SoFi Sponsor break: BetterHelp Sponsor break: Mint Mobile Coroner's immediate recollections of the scene Coroner's concerns about the sheriff's press conference Andy's post-death behavior and insurance The coroner's inquest announcement Andy's response to the inquest Reflections on Heather's life and abuse Supporting domestic violence organizations Introduction to Christy Chupp's story Christy's experience with psychological aggression The cycle of domestic violence and manipulation Christy's childhood and search for love Identity loss after leaving the abuser The fear and uncertainty of leaving Advice for friends and family of victims The importance of background support The turning point: sexual assault Going to the police and seeking help Finding support through social media The role of a supportive friend Christy's recovery and education Andy's statement on Christy's interview Sponsor break: Dark Down East Closing remarks

More from Crime Junkie

MISSING: Lisa Jameson
Nov 16, 2026
SERIAL KILLER: Homer Jackson
Nov 9, 2026
MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Heather Turner
Oct 26, 2026
MURDERED: Nori Amaya
Oct 19, 2026
MISSING: Gregory ‘Keith’ Mann Jr.
Oct 12, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria