Crime Junkie Crime Junkie

INFAMOUS: The Horsch House of Horrors

Oct 5, 2026 · 58m

Summary

This episode investigates the "Horsch House of Horrors" in North Philadelphia, where police discovered disturbing evidence linking Eugene and his late father Raymond to at least seven missing women. The story began when a park ranger found a woman using a stolen ID belonging to missing person Blair Tonzelli with Eugene, leading to a search of their home that revealed chemicals, a grow operation, and a letter referencing serial killers.

Topics discussed

Intro: Parenting, loss, and the need for a safety net Promo: Park Predators podcast Case overview: The Horsch house and missing women The traffic stop: Discovering a stolen ID Arrest of Eugene Horsch and the house search Press conference: Strange setup and unexplained items Dark findings: Letters, fake IDs, and Blair Tonzelli Blair Tonzelli's background and disappearance Eugene Horsch's history: Crime and family dynamics Defense strategy: Shifting blame to Raymond Promo: SimpliSafe home security Raymond Horsch: The 'Sociopath' father Raymond's past: Crime, art, and psychological profile The pattern: Staged death scenes and vulnerable women Connecting Blair Tonzelli to the Horsch house Promo: SoFi student loan refinancing Amy's case: Marriage, disappearance, and police response Investigating Raymond's website and digital evidence The digital trove: 50 hard drives and 600k images Identifying Maribel and Gabrielle from the files Metadata discrepancies and the 5% review status Promo: BetterHelp therapy services New victims: Nicole and the video evidence Jonathan's story: Discovering Nicole's fate FBI verification and lack of physical evidence The urns: Potential remains and identification issues The Garzone scandal: Body parts and Raymond's access Raymond's art show and crematorium connection Neighbor accounts: Barrels, dirt, and hidden items The 2009 bus incident and unexplained IDs The steel door and hidden storage in the house Renovation findings: DVDs and discarded evidence Scale of the case: 60 people identified in footage Conclusion: Ongoing investigation and unanswered questions Outro: Full Body Chills podcast promo

More from Crime Junkie

MISSING: Lisa Jameson
Nov 16, 2026
SERIAL KILLER: Homer Jackson
Nov 9, 2026
MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Heather Turner Part 2
Nov 2, 2026
MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Heather Turner
Oct 26, 2026
MURDERED: Nori Amaya
Oct 19, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria