Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update

Second Date Update: Rock Blocked

Nov 20, 2026 · 18m

Summary

Sarah calls in to discuss her awkward first date with a bouldering instructor named Aaron, who stopped communicating after she requested $90 via Cash App to cover her babysitter and Uber. The hosts ambush Aaron on the phone, revealing Sarah is listening, which leads to a heated argument over whether he should have paid for her childcare. Although Aaron initially refuses a second date due to the financial tension, the hosts attempt to mediate by offering to pay for a new outing.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: Discover Card and Direct Support Careers Hulu Original Series 'All's Fair' Promo Sponsors: Dietz & Watson and Pandora Jewelry Intro: Host banter and listener comments Jeffrey's bird photography goal and Sarah's intro Sarah's bouldering experience and meeting Aaron The first date: Gardening talk and the babysitter issue Hosts discuss why Aaron stopped calling Phone call: Connecting with Aaron Aaron reveals the Cash App $90 request incident Sarah reacts: The dog, the tip, and the argument Attempted reconciliation and the $75 joke Sponsors: Discover Card and Cachava Digestive Boost Post-segment: Hosts reflect on the awkward date Sponsors: Direct Support, Grainger, T-Mobile, IKEA, Pura

More from Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update

Second Date Update Classics: Early Bird Sees The Worm + Miss Krustworthy Returns
Nov 21, 2026
50/50 Fandango: Thanksgiving Edition
Nov 19, 2026
Second Date Update: Go Shorty I'll Pay For Your Birthday
Nov 18, 2026
Awkward Tuesday: Wedding Cake Conundrum
Nov 17, 2026
Second Date Update: Spouse Serenade
Nov 16, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria