Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update

Second Date Update Classics: Early Bird Sees The Worm + Miss Krustworthy Returns

Nov 21, 2026 · 37m

Summary

Brooke and Jeffrey discuss the fine line between vulnerability and oversharing before addressing a listener who accidentally flashed a date while retrieving toilet paper, leading to a rejected second date. The hosts then reconnect with "Miss Crustworthy" regarding a man who ghosted her for two weeks after a Caribbean trip, only to reveal he is actually married and cheating on his wife.

Topics discussed

IKEA Holiday Shopping Ad Hulu 'All's Fair' Series Promo Dietz & Watson and Pandora Jewelry Ads Zolair Prescription Medication Ad Show Merchandise and St. Jude's Charity Intro to Neil's Embarrassing First Date Story Neil's Morning Routine and Breakfast Date The Bathroom Incident and Awkward Hallway Moment Hosts React to Neil's Story Debate on How Neil Should Have Handled It Interview with Erin: Her Side of the Story Confronting Neil and Erin's Final Verdict Advice for Neil and Show Transition IKEA and Dietz & Watson Ads Banter About Pants and Intro to Next Caller Julia 'Miss Crustworthy' Returns with New Guy Ben Discussing Ben's Ghosting and Caribbean Trip Playing a Song and Theories on Ben's Silence Calling Ben: The Caribbean Explanation Reveal: Ben Is Married and Cheating Hosts React to Ben's Infidelity IKEA and Dietz & Watson Ads Debate on Infidelity Statistics and Norms Transition to Next Segment IKEA Holiday Shopping Ad Dietz & Watson Deli Meats Ad Pura Fragrance Diffuser Ad

More from Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update

Second Date Update: Rock Blocked
Nov 20, 2026
50/50 Fandango: Thanksgiving Edition
Nov 19, 2026
Second Date Update: Go Shorty I'll Pay For Your Birthday
Nov 18, 2026
Awkward Tuesday: Wedding Cake Conundrum
Nov 17, 2026
Second Date Update: Spouse Serenade
Nov 16, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria