You're Wrong About You're Wrong About

The JFK Assassination Part 2 with Mackenzie Joy Brennan

Jun 30, 2026 · 2h 31m

Summary

Hosts Michael Hobbes and Mackenzie Joy Brennan examine the origins of JFK assassination conspiracy theories, analyzing how witness confusion, media errors, and public distrust fueled speculation. They debunk early rumors regarding the rifle and Jack Ruby, attributing them to human fallibility rather than plots. The episode then transitions to Jim Garrison’s trial of Clay Shaw, exploring how Oliver Stone’s film *JFK* popularized these narratives for a new generation.

Topics discussed

Introduction: The Kennedy assassination and the nature of rumors Eyewitness confusion, trauma, and the 'multiple Oswalds' phenomenon The open convertible: Security failures and the Popemobile comparison Jack Ruby, the 'witch gun,' and early media narratives The Warren Commission report and the 'lone gunman' conclusion Oliver Stone's JFK movie and the Clay Shaw trial The Clay Shaw conspiracy theory and homosexual panic Truth serum, false confessions, and the Zapruder film The magic bullet theory and ballistics analysis Acoustic evidence and the grassy ridge shooter theory Decerebrate posture and the physical evidence of the shooting Government incompetence vs. conspiracy: The Secret Service failures The Kennedy curse and political dynasty tragedies Why conspiracy theories persist: Psychology and societal distrust
Listen ad-free on Castria