You're Wrong About You're Wrong About

Halloween Listener Special

Oct 23, 2026 · 1h 1m

Summary

In this special Halloween episode, the hosts share listener-submitted memories of the holiday, ranging from nostalgic trick-or-treating adventures and creative costume stories to spooky encounters and personal milestones. The collection highlights diverse experiences, including queer identity exploration, family traditions, and ghostly hauntings, creating a cozy and nostalgic atmosphere that celebrates the liberating and sometimes eerie spirit of Halloween.

Topics discussed

Intro and first listener: Megan's Florida rain story Listener: Trick-or-treating in the rain Listener: Two Halloweens due to parents' divorce Listener: Pants falling down at neighbor's door Listener: Mom brings Halloween to South Africa Listener: Mom's resilience after pepper spray incident Listener: Neighborhood group trick-or-treating in Sonoma Listener: Elderly lady chides first-time trick-or-treater Listener: First time hosting trick-or-treaters Listener: Amanda's springtime Halloween in Melbourne Listener: Family making costumes together Listener: Baby rattle costume detail Listener: First drag experience at 14 Listener: Halloween as safe space for queer expression Listener: Mom's reaction to drag and shared photos Listener: Whittled stick bow costume Listener: Brother encouraging ridiculous costumes Listener: Ziggy Stardust costume and not fitting in Listener: Dressed as the night sky Listener: Foggy mask and car collision Listener: Mistaken for JonBenet Ramsey Listener: Bunny rabbit costume and scary house Listener: Bunnies don't go in trees Listener: Brother teaching egg throwing for Mischief Night Listener: Bombing with shaving cream and eggs Listener: Genie costume and inheriting grandparents' home Listener: Bandmate crush and Scooby costume Listener: Stevie Nicks concert in Alabama Listener: Stevie Nicks wearing witch hat Listener: Suburban haunted house with snakes Listener: Farm haunted house with fake corpse Listener: Hayrack ride and pioneer cemetery Listener: Basement haunted house with phobia themes Listener: Little girl crying after haunted house Listener: Scaredy cat and scarecrow incident Listener: Sobbing wreck after scare Listener: Killer clowns from outer space fear Listener: Lifelong fear of clowns Listener: Managing cemeteries and weird occurrences Listener: Cemetery visit after snowstorm Listener: Car dashboard dying in cemetery Listener: Haunted university campus history Listener: Historical medical experiments on campus Listener: Personal ghost encounter in hallway Listener: Haunted Civil War brass bed Listener: Bed kicking and voice saying 'be nicer' Listener: Meatball appearing in kitchen Listener: 1972 Godfather movie and witch cackle Listener: Running screaming from room Listener: Getting a stray kitten on Halloween Listener: Magical night with new kitten Listener: Proposal and wedding at Halloween party Listener: Halloween as modern Bacchanal Listener: Candy barter system with brothers Listener: Episcopal priest and All Saints Day ritual Listener: Gratitude for different perspective Listener: Community ritual for beloved dead Listener: Samhain fire and story sharing Listener: Headless Robert Shapiro costume Listener: Best friend's death and shared Halloween Listener: Mom's death and Halloween energy Listener: Mask hiding crying on anniversary Listener: Brother Jacob's death and neighbor story Listener: Jacob knocking on doors for sweets Listener: Last Halloween dance and stuffed scarecrow Listener: Late bloomer and special trip Listener: Life's dream trip to America Listener: Halloween Horror Nights and King's house Listener: Kindness of strangers in America Listener: Feeling alone but connected Outro: Happy Halloween wishes End of episode announcement Promo: Where I Live listener special Instructions for voice memo submission Credits and final thanks
Listen ad-free on Castria