Why Is This Happening? The Chris Hayes Podcast Why Is This Happening? The Chris Hayes Podcast

"Maybe We Shouldn't Be Saying Words like 'Deep Red' Anymore"

Nov 6, 2026 · 55m

Summary

Chris Hayes and MS NOW’s director of elections, Kabir Khanna, analyze the historic 2026 midterm results, describing a once-in-50-year Democratic wave driven by massive turnout and significant defection from former Trump voters. The discussion highlights how Republican gerrymandering efforts largely failed to offset these swings, while also examining polling errors and the specific demographic shifts among young, Latino, and independent voters that fueled the unprecedented national popular vote margin.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Wells Fargo Autographed Journey Card Intro: Tennessee race and Blue Wave bingo Election status: Outstanding House and Senate races Historical context: 2018 vs 2024 wave election Introducing Kabir Khanna and the decision desk Early indicators: Indiana and Kentucky results Data analysis: Understanding the data generating process Complete county models and early swing tells Specific district flips: Indiana and Kentucky examples Voting behavior: Early vote vs Election Day vote Polling errors: Understating Democratic support Why polls missed: Trump voter misreporting Defection rates and crossover voting analysis Characterizing the wave: Trump +13 benchmark Historical analogs: 2006 and 2008 elections Sponsor: SimpliSafe Home Security Outstanding races: Maine and Alaska RCV Gerrymandering failure: Texas and Florida maps Gerrymandering impact: California and Utah redraws Incumbent exposure and North Carolina map Long-term effects of gerrymandering on politics Political priorities and future rollback of gains Money in politics: Saturation and utility Turnout vs Persuasion: The two camps Quantifying the impact of persuasion Key swing groups: Independents and young voters Latino and young voter snapback analysis Nerdy data points: Precinct level analysis Voter files and future data validation Psychology of red and blue state perceptions Partisan identity and caucus representation Political psychology: Heuristics and mental shortcuts The purple map: Visualizing mixed voting Party brand perception and voter sentiment Sponsor: SimpliSafe Home Security Corruption as a central election issue Voter priorities: Corruption vs Cost of Living Perception of presidential focus and priorities Economic desires: Price level decline Iconic races: Figures and Boebert Senate races: Louisiana and Tennessee Louisiana Senate: Julia Letlow and Jamie Davis Resource barriers and congressional demographics Mississippi Senate: Uncalled race and absentee ballots Close race logistics and ballot certification Outro: Thanks to Kabir Khanna Sponsor: SimpliSafe Home Security

More from Why Is This Happening? The Chris Hayes Podcast

The Future of Capitalism Now Centers on AI, with Kevin Roose
Nov 17, 2026
The DOJ’s Job Is to Preserve Democracy, Not Attack It. With Rachel Maddow
Nov 10, 2026
Is This America's Next Big Chance to Get Healthcare Right? with Ian Coss
Nov 3, 2026
Conflict Is Not Sin, with Priya Parker
Oct 27, 2026
Is Donald Trump the Right’s Pinnacle of Manhood? with Adam Serwer
Oct 20, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria