Why Are You Laughing? Why Are You Laughing?

The Rise & Fall of Cancel Culture in Comedy

Apr 23, 2026 ยท 1h 49m

Topics discussed

Introduction and the rise and fall of cancel culture Show history, Patreon, and defining the topic The pendulum swing and the Daniel Tosh incident Context, apologies, and the Gilbert Gottfried era Radio controversies and the Jim Norton vs. Lindy West debate Debate dynamics, self-censorship, and the 2012 turning point Online outrage cycles and the Roseanne Barr return Roseanne's apology, business risks, and Owen Benjamin's cancellation Owen Benjamin's career loss and Joe Rogan's advice Deplatforming, influence, and the Kathy Griffin incident Kathy Griffin's backlash and the Jimmy Kimmel apology Late-night blackface sketches and the Me Too movement blur Chris Delia's distancing and the Shane Gillis firing Shane Gillis context, Seth Simons, and Anthony Jeselnik's role Owen Benjamin's Netflix special and the influencer debate Ari Shafir's Kobe Bryant joke and the line of offense Pang Dang, Tony Hinchcliffe, and the 'Kill Tony' phenomenon Patton Oswalt, Dave Chappelle, and the social media amplifier The 2016 peak, Norm Macdonald, and concluding thoughts
Listen ad-free on Castria