WHAT WENT WRONG WHAT WENT WRONG

Witches! A Primer

Sep 11, 2026 · 49m

Summary

Hosts Lizzie and Chris explore the history of witch depictions in film, tracing the archetype from the 15th-century Malleus Maleficarum and the Salem trials to modern cinema. They analyze how societal fears, the printing press, and the rise of Christianity shaped the "evil witch" trope, while later works like The Craft and Practical Magic reclaimed the figure as a symbol of female power and sisterhood. The episode connects historical persecution to contemporary storytelling, highlighting how witches serve as a "canary in the coal mine" for how society treats women.

Topics discussed

Intro, Patreon notice, and Citizens Bank ad Welcome and discussion of witch movies Witches as a canary in the coal mine Heinrich Kramer and the Malleus Maleficarum The printing press and the start of witch hunts Ancient magic and the definition of a witch Saint Augustine and the demonization of pagans Quince and Monarch ads Medieval witchcraft beliefs and legal categories Accusations, paranoia, and the role of healers Tangential discussion on voice analysis and bias Shakespeare's Macbeth and the three witches The Salem witch trials of 1692 Article and Square ads The end of trials and the Brothers Grimm The Wizard of Oz and visual tropes The Love Witch and the Feminine Mystique The 1990s witch reclamation and The Craft Teen witch TV shows and Practical Magic Verizon, Times Square, and Amex ads Practical Magic aesthetics and character dynamics 2010s serious witches and the 2020s shift Analysis of the film Weapons and modern witch imagery Conclusion and teaser for next episode
Listen ad-free on Castria